There’s no avoiding the heightened level of interest, and consequently, the criticism that comes with playing for the Montreal Canadiens. It’s particularly evident for a player such Juraj Slafkovsky, the first overall pick at the 2022 NHL Entry Draft.
The fact that the Canadiens decided to rush him into the NHL plays a part in the equation. Like it or not, he’s been playing in the NHL for three seasons, which opens him up to both reasonable and unreasonable criticism. That wasn’t his decision, mind you, but he does have to live with the consequences of what could arguably be described as rushed development.
With that in mind, given that Slafkovsky is currently part of the oft-maligned crew in Montreal, I thought it would be interesting to verify some of the prevailing perceptions in regard to his play this season.
To do so, I asked for some help from Canadiens fans, who are always happy to oblige when it comes to player analysis.
Before we start, the goal of this article is to verify facts, or bust myths, but that’s not always possible in the realm of publicly available data. I will do my best to avoid providing an opinion, or more accurately, I will do my best to avoid offering an opinion without any semblance of evidence to back it up.
I should also point out the goal isn’t necessarily to defend Slafkovsky. I’ve often been accused of going out of my way to defend players who are receiving the brunt of the criticism from the media and fans alike, and while there’s probably some truth to that, I am a slave to the numbers. If Slafkovsky is playing well in some situations, the numbers will let me know.
Essentially, athletes write the book, but I adapt the screen play. There’s a certain level of responsibility involved in presenting the data to the public, but If I am defending a player, it’s usually because the facts suggest he merits less criticism.
Today we will investigate five Juraj Slafkovsky-related myths, but considering we had over 100 submissions from fans within just a few minutes, we may end up making this a regular feature, covering all the potential Canadiens myths, past or present.
Dave Cassin (@willi_39) says: “His passing is underrated. He can find a stick blade more often than not from across the ice.”
Facts: While some have stated Slafkovsky is a little less useful from an offensive standpoint, the truth is that he’s producing much more at 5v5, showing encouraging growth in that respect since he joined the league. He’s playing a little less at 5v5 than he did last year, though part of that involved his confusing assignment to the fourth line while he was the team’s third-highest scorer.
He’s scoring fewer goals than he did in both his freshman and sophomore seasons, and that’s definitely a concern, but we also have to be mindful that he never really projected as a goalscorer in the first place.
As Dave correctly pointed out, Slafkovsky is a playmaker. Furthermore, he’s the most productive player in the lineup when it comes to generating primary assists, as he leads the team with 1.07 per 60.
It’s really what has driven his improved scoring rate this season. Slafkovsky more than doubled his primary assist rate in 2024-25, connoting that he’s been a crucial part of the first-line’s success in plays leading up to goals.
MYTH CONFIRMED
Anne Labrecque (@AnneLabrecque1) says: “We could argue he’s going through a sophomore slump, even if this is his third season, as he has dealt with injuries in the past.”
Facts: While the traditional ‘peak years’ for athletes were once considered between the ages of 28 and 32, the truth is that most athletes hit their prime much earlier. Recent studies suggest it’s closer to 22 or 23 when discussing offensive production.
Therefore, we can reasonably suggest that Anne’s point, which is that Slafkovsky is still quite young, and has only recently reached 160 games played despite being in the NHL since he was 18, is worth adding to the mix.
Of course, most of the athletes included in recent studies don’t start playing in the NHL at 18, which means that Slafkovsky already has the type of experience that most players only achieve by the time they hit 22 or 23, another variable worth keeping in mind.
In other words, he’s young, but he’s also ahead of the curve from an experience standpoint.
MYTH PLAUSIBLE
Cameradarren (@habs1973) says: “He appears to be hesitant on contact at times. Makes me think he’s favouring something.”
Facts: I don’t love to speculate as to injuries, but I’d be lying if I said I did not have the same impression at times.
If we do look for some evidence as to his hesitancy to deliver hits, there’s not much there to confirm the perception that he’s been a little ‘soft’ this year, so to speak. For the record, several fans made the same type of comment in regard to Slafkovsky avoiding physical play, I don’t want to give the impression I’m trying to dunk on one opinion.
That being said, Slafkovsky is hitting much more often this year, to the tune of 10.4 hits per 60 at 5v5, which represents almost a 40 percent increase compared to the previous season.
He’s also getting hit almost 50 percent less often, though you can interpret that in two different ways. The first would be that he’s learned from his rough start in the league, which saw several opponents lay him out with big, clean hits. The other is that he’s avoiding dirty areas when he has the puck, but I genuinely don’t get that impression when watching him in the offensive zone.
Regardless, since he’s hitting a lot more than he did in year one or two, I think we can safely say this particular myth is probably not accurate.
MYTH BUSTED
Bill Tyros (@BillTyros) says: “He’s struggling with puck control, losing the majority of one-on-one battles, and making some costly turnovers.”
Facts: I don’t have to check the numbers to confirm this is true, but we will anyhow, because it’s such a significant issue within Slafkovsky’s game that we’d be delving into intellectual dishonesty by ignoring the statistical change.
As you can see in the chart taken from Natural Stat Trick, Slafkovsky is giving away the puck almost 80 percent more this year. Additionally, he’s also generating fewer takeaways, compounding an already difficult change in results.
He leads all forwards in giveaways, to the point that he’s coughing up the puck with the same frequency as defencemen Lane Hutson and Mike Matheson, though they have the puck on their stick much more frequently.
We have seen some noted improvements from Slafkovsky when it comes to puck management, especially compared to the first few weeks of the year, but he will have to do a much better job protecting the puck if he’s to permanently gain Martin St-Louis’ trust.
He also has to generate a lot more takeaways, like he did on Friday night versus the Washington Capitals.
The Cole Caufield goal last night obviously doesn’t happen without Juraj Slafkovsky’s great pass.
But the play all started with Slaf stealing the puck in the neutral zone, followed by him winning a board battle.
It’s the little plays that add to the big moments. pic.twitter.com/ckiYkRnoQM
— /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) January 11, 2025
Hadi Kalakeche (@HadiK_Scouting) says “IMHO, the issue plaguing Slafkovsky is at the intersection of old-school and new-school analysis. He just needs to skate. He rarely reaches 20mph on-puck, if ever. I don’t have the NHL Edge stats in front of me, but I don’t see him using bursts of speed to solve problems.”
Facts: I wouldn’t exactly qualify Hadi as a fan, he’s more of the expert variety when it comes to player analysis, but he does bring up an interesting aspect of Slafkovsky’s play.
I’ve been keeping an eye on the NHL Edge stats, though you haven’t seen them used on this site very often because I’m not quite sure what the baselines should look like, which makes data analysis based solely on those stats difficult, if not impossible.
But we can compare Slafkovsky’s results to those produced by his linemates, Nick Suzuki and Cole Caufield, to get a better idea of how much pace they bring to the table. It’s not ideal, as the information provided by Edge is all-situations, not just 5v5.
I’ll simply post the results from the three top-line players and allow you to draw your own conclusions, but suffice it to say, Hadi is 100 percent correct that speed bursts are an issue for the youngest player in the Canadiens lineup, especially compared to his most common linemates.
Suzuki NHL Edge Skating Stats:
Slafkovsky NHL Edge Skating Stats
MYTH CONFIRMED
Montreal Canadiens statistics are 5v5 unless otherwise noted, via Natural Stat Trick and NHL Edge.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
The Montreal Canadiens may have lost to the Washington Capitals in the first round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs, but they made sure to set off some fireworks while they could. In Game 3, as the Canadiens and Capitals were heading to the locker room for the second intermission, a brawl broke out between the two teams. Scrums broke out between the players, with the peak coming from Canadiens forward Josh Anderson and Capitals forward Tom Wilson mixing it up on the bench. Anderson and Wilson started their fight on the ice, but an open door to the Capitals bench forced their momentum off the playing surface. The brawl between the Canadiens and Capitals ended up being one of the biggest highlights of the playoffs, but no one really knew why it started. A couple of Canadiens players cleared the air recently on what sparked the melee. According to Canadiens defenseman Arber Xhekaj, backup goalie Jakub Dobes was chirping and trash talking everyone on the Canadiens all game from his bench. “He’s looking over, he’s chirping every single guy that comes off the ice,” Xhekaj said. “He’s yelling at them, chirping them. Next thing you know, our goalie gets hurt and Doby has to go in. Uh oh.” After about 11 minutes of the second period, Canadiens starting goalie Sam Montembeault suffered an injury, forcing Dobes to between the pipes for his first career playoff appearance. “That is true,” Dobes said. “They definitely were not nice to me the first five minutes.” Xhekaj went on to add more detail about the brawl starting, noting that the Capitals were waiting on the ice to have a few word with Dobes. “The periods over, so the other team has to skate across the ice and Doby has to skate through all of them,” Xhekaj said. “Nobody left, they just waited for Doby because they wanted to have a word with him. Then I got in there and it was madness.” Game 3 ended up being the only win the Canadiens had in the series, picking up a 6-3 victory. Dobes was credited with the win, making seven saves on eight shots in his relief effort.
The New York Yankees (59-49) have already been quite busy as buyers ahead of the July 31 (6 p.m. EST) trade deadline. Third baseman Ryan McMahon, infielder Amed Rosario and outfielder Austin Slater have all been added to the fold over the last week as Brian Cashman looks to push his roster over the top in pursuit of a World Series. While the Yankees have been active, they've done so without giving up any of their top prospects. Outfielder Spencer Jones continues to be a hot commodity around baseball, though New York is hesitant to deal him. Unless that is for Pirates superstar starting pitcher Paul Skenes, that is. MLB insider Jon Heyman shared the report on Thursday afternoon. Cashman and the Yankees clearly hold Jones in very high regard, which makes sense given he's lit up both AA and AAA in 2025. The 24-year-old is batting an impressive .402 with 13 HRs and 25 RBI in just 21 games since getting called up to the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders. His 6'7, 240-pound frame and skillset as a left-handed hitter are tantalizing, and he'll be ready to make an impact at the big league level sooner rather than later. Despite that, there's no question the Yankees should and would be willing to put him on the table in a trade for Skenes. The 23-year-old has been absolutely dominant to start his MLB career, with a 1.89 earned run average through his first 45 starts. He's already emerged as one of, if not the best, pitchers in baseball, with plenty of room to grow. The Pirates (47-62) have shown zero inclination or willingness to move on from Skenes, though you have to figure that teams like the Yankees will continue to call as long as Pittsburgh continues to struggle. It feels like a pipe dream for now, but holding out hope for Skenes to one day become available could be worth the wait, and no prospect would be excluded in such a deal.
With things moving quickly at the trade deadline, a potential target for the Chicago Cubs has come off the board. The Cubs have done a nice job so far of improving their pitching staff, but there have been some notable relievers who have moved so far. While Chicago has already added Andrew Kittredge, he is more of a middle reliever than a potential eighth or ninth inning pitcher. Adding an impact arm like Jhoan Duran or Ryan Helsley would have been ideal yesterday, but they have also now reportedly missed out on David Bednar. According to Jeff Passan, the talented right-hander from the Pittsburgh Pirates is going to be heading to the New York Yankees. After Duran and Helsley came off the board, Bednar was the next best option, and it was the Yankees who won the bidding war. So far this year, he has totaled a 2.37 ERA and 17 saves in 42 appearances. Due to the struggles of the Pirates, there haven’t been a ton of save opportunities for Bednar, but he has no doubt been one of the best closers in baseball this campaign. This would have been the type of impact addition that many are expecting Chicago to make before the deadline. However, with the former All-Star off the board, there aren’t many closers left that can help the Cubs. With that being said, it will be interesting to see if Chicago looks to get more in the starting pitcher market to improve the team in that area, rather than the bullpen. The Latest Chicago Cubs News Cubs Refusing To Include Top Prospect In Talks Ahead of MLB Trade Deadline Long-Rumored Cubs Bullpen Trade Target Gets Shipped To Tigers Cubs Among Teams Still Attempting To Acquire Nationals Pitcher Cubs Reveal Special Ryne Sandberg Tribute Jerseys To Be Worn Saturday
Much-needed bullpen help has arrived for the New York Yankees. The Bronx Bombers are acquiring Pittsburgh Pirates closer David Bednar in exchange for three prospects, with the full trade first reported by MLB Network's Jon Morosi. The Yankees entered play on July 31 with a 4.24 bullpen ERA, which ranked 21st in MLB. Therefore, David Bednar represents a significant upgrade for a unit that sorely needed one. It's been a remarkable in-season turnaround for Bednar, who is only a few months removed from posting a 5.14 ERA in nine April appearances and nearly being ousted as Pirates closer. Since then, the veteran reliever has excelled, with a 1.61 ERA from May 1 onward. Pittsburgh turns Bednar, who has one year of arbitration remaining, into three solid prospects, headlined by catcher Rafael Flores, the Yankees' No. 8 prospect. The Pirates also received 14th-ranked prospect Edgleen Perez, who receives high marks for his bat as a catcher. The third prospect heading to the Steel City is outfielder Brian Sanchez, who is unranked but currently at Single-A. The price for controllable relievers has been high, to be sure. But it was one the Yankees needed to pay with both Luke Weaver and Devin Williams struggling, while righty Fernando Cruz tends to injury. With Bednar now in the fold, New York can feel much more secure in closing out games, leaving the others to set up roles as the Yankees attempt to chase down the AL East-leading Toronto Blue Jays. Meanwhile, this trade marks the second significant piece that the Pirates have moved leading up to the deadline, with third baseman Ke'Bryan Hayes being dealt to the Cincinnati Reds on Wednesday.