x
Montreal Canadiens Overreactions at the Quarter-Mark
Montreal Canadiens goalie Jakub Dobes and teammate forward Cole Caufield celebrate a win (Eric Bolte-Imagn Images)

With a quarter of the 2026-27 campaign in the books, the moment is ripe for a pair of stimulating exercises. For one, fellow Montreal Canadiens scribe Ryan Szporer has offered his assessment of the club’s performance thus far. That’s the more studious, no-sugar angle to broach the topic. The other embraces a bit more spice: responses to overreactions. Or are they overreactions? Therein lies the fun. Let’s discuss.

Jacob Fowler Has Solved Montreal’s Goalie Issues

No, he has not, at least not in the long term.

It is extremely tempting to agree with the claim that the Canadiens need no longer fret about which netminder they can rely on for the future. After all, 21-year-old Jacob Fowler has captivated the fanbase, earned the trust of the coaching staff and his teammates, and flummoxed the opposition since the season’s start.

Not only does the eye test favour him – he’s poised, technically sound, and athletic – but his numbers are inspiring, to say the least. Despite the 3-1 defeat to the New York Rangers on Nov. 16, Fowler sports a 2.21 goals-against average (GAA), a save percentage (SV%) of .923, and a resplendent record of 9-2-2. The GAA, SV%, and number of wins are all top-10-worthy, with the SV% good for a spot in the top five.

Even recent Hall of Fame inductee Carey Price revealed that he sees himself in young Fowler. So, what on earth could be the issue?

We don’t have to think far back to when supporters were excited about an unexpected chase for a Stanley Cup Playoffs berth, helped no less by a beloved local, Québécois netminder named Samuel Montembeault. It was during the 2024-25 campaign, two seasons ago. He was Montreal’s number one keeper.

Furthermore, we need only think back to last season when yet another goalie wowed Bell Centre faithful and dumbfounded opponents: Jakub Dobes. He was the number one keeper.

And yet…here we go again? Fowler is amazing. He’s putting up better numbers than the previous two goalies. There is still a nagging feeling that this perpetual debate about who is the true number one starter in Montreal is not over. We’ve been here before. Twice. Literally the last two years.

Frankly, it will feel right to proclaim Fowler as the undisputed choice if he starts most games next season.

Juraj Slafkovsky Is a Bust

No, but one must read between the lines and demonstrate patience.

Consider this a supplemental piece to an article The Hockey Writers published last week about Slafkovsky’s slow start to the present campaign. 

There is considerable pressure on anyone who spends most nights on the top offensive line and as one of the playmakers on a power-play unit. We’ve gone through the in-depth statistics courtesy of Money Puck in last week’s piece. To be blunt, his actual goals scored above expected is appalling (minus-5.8), and his goals scored per 60 minutes vis-à-vis those expected is woeful (0.31).

The fact of the matter is that he is involved. Were he not, the stats in the expected numbers columns would not be as high as they are. Yes, it would be better if Slafkovsky cashed in on more of his opportunities. There remain 63 matches to do just that. 

If he played with an air of disinterest, looking lackadaisical on too many shifts, then fans could genuinely worry. But that’s not the case. Anything but, in fact. Although he isn’t scoring goals, he’s creating many opportunities for his linemates. He ranks fourth on the club in points with 13, 11 of those being helpers. For as pitiful as the team’s power play has been, he’s tallied four assists on the special teams. 

The fact is that he’s playing with some fire in his belly, which is what the Canadiens will need as they traverse a dangerous segment of their schedule, both regarding injuries and upcoming opponents.

Caufield Will Hit 50 Goals Again

Yes. It might be tight, but yes.

Through 21 matches, Cole Caufield has netted 12 goals. Multiply that figure by four – since we are discussing the quarter-mark – and we have 48. It’s close, and the star forward would need a bit of fortune. A bounce here, a “post-and-in” there, but he can certainly pull it off. 

If any Canadiens player has any chance of doing it, it’s him. His expected goals for is 8.8, placing him 33rd league-wide. He’s already in a multi-player tie for ninth with his dozen markers, and his goals above expected is a healthy 3.2, good for 24th.

He has a nose for the goal and can seemingly score from any angle. About the only thing he hasn’t done this season is perform a Michigan. He is a pure scorer and is playing quite well this season through 21 games. Barring an injury or a bewildering slump, he is at least on pace to threaten for 50 goals.

The Canadiens Are Stanley Cup Contenders

No, they are not. 

That was the expectation heading into the season. Nay, it remains the expectation. The reality is far more nuanced. 

They are currently in a three-way tie for first in the Atlantic Division along with rivals, the Boston Bruins and Tampa Bay Lightning. Their 12-5-4 record is solid. We’ve waxed poetic about Fowler and Caufield and remain cautiously optimistic about Slafkovsky. We haven’t referenced captain Nick Suzuki and stud blueliner Lane Hutson in this article up until now.

What’s the problem?

For one, to compete for a Stanley Cup, one needs to play in the final round. At this point in time, it looks glaringly obvious that the road to the Final in the Eastern Conference goes through the Carolina Hurricanes. The same Hurricanes who whooped the Canadiens in the Eastern Conference Final last season and who happily spoiled this season’s home opener.

The Nov. 10 contest at home to the Minnesota Wild was another stern test. Montreal lost 2-1.

On Nov. 14, they hosted a beleaguered Colorado Avalanche side sans Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. Rather, a Colorado team thought to be beleaguered. Not so. The Avalanche skated to a 4-1 win. 

The ignominious 5-4 overtime defeat to the Winnipeg Jets, anyone?

These are not results belonging to a club with the “Stanley Cup contender” moniker attached. 

Can they win the Stanley Cup? Sure. With goaltending as they have, top-level talent, a great captain, and impressive depth, why not?

Is what they have accomplished thus far enough to grant them the title of contender? No. It’s been too imperfect a season. Too many bumps in the road. Too many nights that make one question how good exactly this team is.

Too Soon to Overreact

The present exercise was written with a smidgeon of mirth. Let’s keep it real: the team is 21 games into an 84-game slugfest, excluding a potentially long postseason run. Now is not actually the time to overreact. When the Canadiens win 20 games in a row or go 1-9 through 10, then we’ll talk. Even so, observing what the fanbase as well as analysts are commenting on, one can tell that a lot of people think this edition of the Canadiens can be very special.

And if the team does win the Stanley Cup, would climbing up a lamppost in downtown Montreal on Ste-Catherine Street be an overreaction?

Absolutely not.

This article first appeared on The Hockey Writers and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!