Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Oilers Made Huge Mistake Signing Campbell Over Kuemper
Jack Campbell, Edmonton Oilers (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

It hasn’t been the best series for goaltender Darcy Kuemper, although he has come up with several big saves at opportune times for the Los Angeles Kings, particularly in their wins over the Edmonton Oilers in Games 1 and 2 of the first-round series. On the Oilers’ side, Calvin Pickard has done that to an extent, although the Oilers’ offence over the past two games has been a bigger part as to why they have been able to even up the series. Stuart Skinner, meanwhile, failed to provide any big saves for the group, which is why he has been stapled to the bench for each of the past two outings.

Despite Kuemper’s up-and-down series, Kings fans are confident having him between the pipes. The 34-year-old had an outstanding regular season and was just named a finalist for the Vezina Trophy. It’s an ugly reminder of what could have been for the Oilers.

Oilers Had Opportunity to Sign Kuemper

In 2022, the Oilers went into free agency looking to upgrade their goaltending after their duo of Mikko Koskinen and Mike Smith didn’t work out. It was known that Skinner would be their backup heading into the 2022-23 season, though a starter they could rely on was still needed. They ultimately chose to sign former Toronto Maple Leaf Jack Campbell to a five-year, $25 million deal. It was a risky move since Campbell didn’t have a track record as an NHL starter, and it quickly proved to be catastrophic.

Campbell became the rookie Skinner’s backup in the first season of his deal and into the second. After that second season, he was bought out and hasn’t found an NHL home since. The move is all the more disappointing when you realize the Oilers could have signed Kuemper.

He was also a free agent that offseason and signed a five-year, $26.25 million contract with the Washington Capitals. He also didn’t play particularly well in his two seasons with the Capitals, though his numbers were far superior to Campbell’s. After being traded to the Kings this past offseason, he’s become a reliable starter again, which he was for several seasons with the Arizona Coyotes and Colorado Avalanche.

Had the Oilers signed Kuemper, they would have a starting netminder who is a top-15, if not top-10, NHL starter and with Skinner as his backup, the team would have a much better chance at the Stanley Cup. Maybe they would have won it last season.

Oilers Looking for a Goalie Again

With wins in Games 3 and 4, the Oilers have tied the series 2-2, but many are counting them out because of their goaltending situation. It was a situation many fans had hoped they would resolve at the 2025 Trade Deadline, though general manager Stan Bowman ultimately chose to stick with Skinner. Had they just gone with Kuemper in free agency back in 2022, all of these issues would be out the window.

The Oilers will again have to address their goaltending situation this offseason, regardless of how the playoffs play out. Despite many opportunities, Skinner has failed to prove that he can be a trusted number-one goalie for the organization going forward. He’s capable of putting some great starts together, but his inconsistent play makes him an unreliable starter.

It’s easy to look back on it in hindsight, but you can’t help but question why the Oilers never seemingly had interest in Kuemper. He’s just two years older than Campbell, and had a far better track record. The fact that Kuemper’s five-year deal cost just $1.25 million more over the duration of the contract proves that the Oilers certainly could have afforded to do so, though for whatever reason, they preferred Campbell. That move was clearly a mistake, one that is haunting this fan base, and one that could haunt them even more should the Kings wind up coming out on top of this series.

This article first appeared on The Hockey Writers and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Two Vancouver Canucks Prospects Invited To Prestigious Summer Hockey Tournament
NHL

Two Vancouver Canucks Prospects Invited To Prestigious Summer Hockey Tournament

The Vancouver Canucks have an interesting prospect group, and now Braeden Cootes and Wilson Bjorck are invited to a top NHL Summer Showcase. Braeden Cootes was a top pick of the Vancouver Canucks in the 2025 NHL Draft, and quickly he's become a fan favourite, with the team inking him to a three-year Entry Level Deal shortly after being drafted. Now, he's catching attention around the league, as he, along with Wilson Bjorck, a fifth-round pick in the 2025 NHL Draft have now been invited to the NHL's World Juniors Summer Showcase. Cootes, a native of Alberta will continue to make his case for a spot on the Team Canada 2025 World Juniors squad, while Bjorck is firming as an intriguing piece for what could be a highly competitive Swedish squad at the tournament. Last season, Cootes had 63 points in 60 games played for the WHL's Seattle Thunderbirds, and given the two-way game that he brings to the ice, he could be a very valuable piece for Canada at the tournament, with the Canucks already valuing him highly as a potential middle-six centre of the future. As for Bjorck, he went highly underrated in the draft process this year, and after putting up 67 points in 43 games for Djurgardens Jr. last season, if he can continue to develop physically, he is certainly a piece for the Canucks fans to watch moving forward. Ultimately, this just goes to show what a promising prospect group the Canucks have been building in recent years, and if the duo of Cootes and Bjorck among others from this draft class pan out, the future remains very bright in Vancouver.

Cowboys make questionable move amid Micah Parsons stalemate 
NFL

Cowboys make questionable move amid Micah Parsons stalemate 

The Dallas Cowboys extended one of their stars Sunday, just not the one fans wanted them to pay. At Cowboys training camp Saturday, Dallas fans serenaded owner Jerry Jones with "Pay Micah [Parsons]" chants. The EDGE, of course, is set to play on the fifth-year option of his rookie contract this season. Jones must not have been listening. He gave tight end Jake Ferguson a new contract instead. Dallas and the 26-year-old pass-catcher agreed to a four-year, $52M contract extension, via NFL Media's Ian Rapoport. This move seems head-scratching. Parsons has won the 2021 Defensive Rookie of the Year and earned two first-team All-Pro nods since the Cowboys took him with pick No. 12 in the 2021 NFL Draft. The 26-year-old EDGE also finished second in Defensive Player of the Year voting during the 2021 and 2022 seasons. Ferguson, meanwhile, is solid but not elite. In three seasons with the Cowboys, the 2022 fourth-round pick has made one Pro Bowl and has never finished with more than 761 receiving yards in a season. An extension for Parsons will devour future cap space. The Cowboys may be worried about that after giving quarterback Dak Prescott (four years, $240M) and wide receiver CeeDee Lamb (four years, $136M) long-term deals in 2024. Pittsburgh Steelers EDGE T.J. Watt signed a lucrative three-year, $123M extension on July 17, making him the league's highest-paid non-QB. Parsons could command a similar contract. If cap space is Dallas' primary concern, however, why would it extend Ferguson? He's now set to be the NFL's seventh-highest-paid TE. The Cowboys waited to extend Lamb and Prescott just before the start of the 2024 season. They may be doing the same with Parsons. The star defender has said, "Ownership is always gonna make [contract negotiations] drag out." Regardless, the Cowboys should've paid Parsons before Ferguson. That's a much bigger priority for the team.

Mets Make Mark Vientos Decision After Luis Robert Jr. Trade Report
MLB

Mets Make Mark Vientos Decision After Luis Robert Jr. Trade Report

Right-handed slugger Mark Vientos is in his fourth season with the New York Mets after making his debut in 2022. The 24-year-old emerged as a rising star for New York last year, playing 111 games and posting career highs with a .266 batting average and an .837 OPS. He also elevated his performance in the 2024 postseason, batting .327 with 18 hits, five home runs, 14 RBIs and eight runs scored in 13 games, leading the Mets to an NLCS appearance. Vientos recently recovered from a right hamstring strain that sidelined him for a few weeks in June, but since then he has really struggled to return to form and regain his production at the plate. Ahead of Sunday’s series finale against the San Francisco Giants, the Mets decided to bench Vientos (the second time in the last three games). The decision to leave him out of the lineup came after Bob Nightengale reported that the Chicago White Sox require Vientos to be involved in any trade for center fielder Luis Robert Jr. Mets general manager David Stearns recently said the Mets will be “engaged” when it comes to possibly adding a center fielder, so addressing that outfield need and Vientos losing playing time may push the organization to part ways with him. In 2025, Vientos is hitting .226 with a .638 OPS, six home runs and 27 RBIs, a steep drop-off in production after his breakout year. He will remain under team control for five more seasons after 2025 and will not hit free agency until 2030.

Aaron Rodgers responds to criticism from Steelers legend Terry Bradshaw
NFL

Aaron Rodgers responds to criticism from Steelers legend Terry Bradshaw

The Pittsburgh Steelers' signing of quarterback Aaron Rodgers was an immediately polarizing move that did not sit well with large portions of the fan base. It also did not sit well with one of the team's all-time greatest players, four-time Super Bowl winning quarterback Terry Bradshaw. Bradshaw initially referred to the signing of Rodgers as a "joke" and that he should "stay in California and go chew bark" in reference to Rodgers isolating himself in a darkness retreat last year. On Saturday, Rodgers finally had a chance to respond to Bradshaw and did so with a combination of taking the high road, and also trying to make light of it. “I whisper to the gods every single day. I’ve known Terry for a long time, being a part of Fox. Terry’s a legend. He’s an absolute legend. He won four Super Bowls. He’s had a legendary career in the media. But Terry, like a lot of people, doesn’t know me. And so, he’s got an idea of what he thinks about me based on what I’ve done, the documentary, what I’ve said, darkness retreat, whatever the hell you want to talk about. I’d love to get to know Terry on a deeper level. I feel like if he gave me a chance to get to know him, then we’d have a good friendship." He ended the answer by saying, "So, I’d love to get to know Terry on a deeper level if he’s open to it. And maybe we can go chew some bark or whatever the hell he’s talking about together.” The Steelers were in a pretty desperate quarterback situation this offseason after completely overhauling the position for a second year in a row. They missed out on the chance to re-sign Justin Fields, let Russell Wilson walk, missed out on every other veteran who changed teams and passed on the opportunity to select a quarterback near the top of a weak quarterback draft class. (They ultimately selected Ohio State's Will Howard in the sixth round.) The whole Rodgers saga has been quite a soap opera for the Steelers as they waited around for months while he decided on whether or not he wanted to play this season, and if he wanted to play for the Steelers. Add in the fact he has had a tendency to cause some off-field distractions with his comments and weekly "Pat McAfee Show" appearances, as well as the fact he will turn 42 years old this season and hasn't been a top-tier quarterback in three years, and a lot of Steelers fans — and former players — were put off by the idea. The only thing that will matter in the end, however, is how Rodgers plays on the field. He has said all of the right things since joining the team, and his new teammates have all spoken highly of him so far, but it will still come down to results on the field. The Steelers have not won a playoff game in eight years and are facing added pressure each year to end that drought. They are hoping Rodgers has one more good year in him to help them advance in the postseason.