
The Pittsburgh Penguins did it again. They managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by blowing yet another third-period lead, and this one might have been the worst yet. Not only was it the worst one they have had this season, but it reached a historically bad level.
Protecting third-period leads and playing good situational hockey have been season-long problems for the Penguins.
Their 6-5 overtime loss on Saturday, which came after they had built up a 5-1 lead in the third period, was already their fifth loss of the season when leading after two periods, a staggeringly high number to achieve in just a third of a season. That also does not include games where they were tied after two periods, took the lead in the third period, and still lost.
Saturday's game was the third blown lead of the week, following a 3-2 overtime loss to the Dallas Stars last Sunday, where they allowed a game-tying goal in the final minute before losing in overtime, and then an even more incomprehensible loss on Tuesday to the Anaheim Ducks, where they allowed a game-tying goal with 0.1 seconds to play.
Including the two goals they allowed late in the third period on Saturday, they have allowed four goals in their past four games when opponents have pulled their goalie.
It just seems like a fragile, broken team that crumbles at the first sign of adversity.
What makes Saturday's loss even more stunning is that their lead was 5-1 with less than 14 minutes to play in regulation. It was the fifth-latest four-goal comeback (or blown lead from the Penguins' perspective) in NHL history.
The Penguins allowed the fifth-latest four-goal comeback win in NHL history.
— Wes Crosby (@OtherNHLCrosby) December 13, 2025
The Sharks' rally began at 47:33. That's behind:
-- Kings (52:46 on Nov. 10, 2007)
-- Sabres (51:25 on March 10, 1976)
-- Stars (50:01 on Oct. 21, 1993)
-- Islanders (48:21 on March 14, 1987)
The Penguins ended up losing in overtime, continuing another problem where they are now just 1-8 in games that go beyond regulation.
That is a lot of points left on the table.
The blown leads are also a lot of leads left on the table.
Along with the aforementioned games this week, they also had a 3-0 third-period lead against the Toronto Maple Leafs that turned into a 5-3 regulation loss earlier in the season.
The Penguins have greatly exceeded expectations so far this season, and even with all of these issues are still very much in the Eastern Conference playoff race. They are also showing signs of being a good team by being able to outplay teams for 55-58 minutes every night. They just fizzle and crumble at the first sign of adversity. It now seems to be a case where they almost expect to let these leads slip away.
They are still in the playoff race for now. They will not be for long if they do not figure out how to protect leads. Especially big leads in the third period of games.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!