Penguins prospect Peyton Kettles to undergo surgery

The Pittsburgh Penguins won’t get to watch one of their recent top picks for some time. The WHL’s Kelowna Rockets defenseman Peyton Kettles has suffered a shoulder injury that will require surgery, the junior team announced on Tuesday. Kettles is listed as out indefinitely, likely jeopardizing his chance to crack Team Canada’s lineup at the 2026 World Junior Championships.

Pittsburgh drafted Kettles in the second round, marking what was yet another controversial pick from general manager Kyle Dubas and his team at the 2025 NHL Draft. To some, Kettles’ long reach and shutdown defense stood out like gold among a draft class lacking projectable fundamentals. But to others, his lack of jump or offensive upside seemed to hold him back.

Kettles has worked to alleviate those latter concerns through the early season. He recorded two points and seven penalty minutes — one minor penalty and one fight — in two games with the Swift Current Broncos to start the season. Then, he was traded to Kelowna in a truly massive deal that sent defenseman Jackson Gillespie, one first-round pick, two second-round picks and two fourth-round picks back to Swift Current. Just over two weeks after that deal, Kettles will now land on the sideline.

This is an unfortunate blow for a defender who was not only on the rise, but truly working to silence his doubters. He is still a projectable pro talent, playing with a strong stick and patient fundamentals that mirrors many current Penguins defensemen, like Jack St. Ivany and Ryan Shea. Surgery is far from the most ideal outcome, but it will hopefully help Pittsburgh ensure that the reigning 39th-overall pick is able to work back to full health with no complications.

Kettles was on pace for 33 points, 165 penalty minutes, and a plus-22 through 55 games this season prior to his injury, per EliteProspects. He’ll hope to continue marching towards that lofty statline before the Spring, though more about his true timeline will likely be revealed in the weeks to come.