Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Renewed Trade Talk Surrounds Maple Leafs’ Nick Robertson
Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images

In a recent discussion on The Athletic’s podcast, James Mirtle joined host JD Bunkis to delve into the potential future of Toronto Maple Leafs winger Nick Robertson amid a sluggish start to the season. Both analysts reflected on Robertson’s performance and the possibility that he might become a trade candidate if his play does not improve. Is trade talk something that will happen every time Robertson goes on a slump? Or, are the Maple Leafs truly ready to make a deal?

You can see the interview below.

There Were High Expectations for Robertson in Toronto This Season

Mirtle noted that the Maple Leafs hoped Robertson would be a driving offensive force on the ice. He pointed out that there were promising moments, particularly in the season opener, when Robertson showed his skills and looked dangerous. He skated through the neutral zone and created offensive chances. However, these flashes of brilliance have become less frequent as the season advances.

As the conversation continued, Mirtle remarked on Robertson’s tendency to be absent during games. He compared Robertson’s recent play to a “ghost.” He highlighted the stark contrast between his impactful moments and those stretches where he seems invisible, even when receiving minimal ice time. When Robertson gets a chance, he doesn’t seem to show up.

If this trend continues, Mirtle believes that Robertson could return to the potential trade candidate list—where he was before preseason training camp.

Potential Trade Considerations If Robertson Doesn’t Score

Mirtle speculated that if Robertson maintains his current pace, putting up only two points in the first 18 games, the Maple Leafs might reassess their options. Although Robertson’s salary is not a significant burden, the lack of offense could encourage the team to explore trade possibilities. Mirtle noted that, at this point in the season, the focus might shift to other players who have been more effective. That might move Robertson back into trade discussions.

He doesn’t believe moving Robertson would be about the money. Instead, it’s about the organization and the player coming together and saying, “It’s just not working here.”

The Bottom Line: What Lies Ahead for Robertson?

If Mirtle is correct, Robertson’s performance will be a tipping point for the team and his future as a Maple Leafs player. If he can’t find his footing and contribute offensively, the Maple Leafs may feel they have no choice but to trade him. Suddenly, after a solid preseason, Robertson isn’t showing up.

That situation raises questions about the team’s long-term plans for him. It’s a situation worth watching.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST

Maple Leafs Top Prospect Shatters Expectations at World Junior Showcase
NHL

Maple Leafs Top Prospect Shatters Expectations at World Junior Showcase

The World Junior Summer Showcase is in full swing, and Maple Leafs top prospect Ben Danford is shattering expectations, truly proving how good of a player he can be. The Toronto Maple Leafs' defensive prospect, Ben Danford, is among the 44 players who were invited to Hockey Canada's World Juniors Summer Showcase. Hockey Canada finally unveiled the 44 prospects who will head to Minnesota for the showcase, after they held the roster release back while the organization dealt with several injuries, which begins Sunday and runs through August 2 in Minneapolis. Defensive prospect Ben Danford is the only Maple Leafs player invited to the annual showcase, where Canada's World Junior staff will get their first look at what their team might look like for the 2026 World Juniors, which will also take place in Minnesota in December. Danford is being called the best player at the World Juniors Summer Showcase Danford has been exceeding expectations, and one source revealed that he has been the best player at the World Junior Showcase so far. The source said Danford is steady, smart, and hard to ignore on the ice. 'Ben Danford has been the best player at the World Junior Showcase he's steady, smart, and impossible to ignore. Makes every shift count, whether he's breaking up plays or starting the rush. Canada's blue line is in good hands.' - An unnamed source The Maple Leafs selected Danford with their first pick (31st overall) at the 2024 NHL Draft. During his visit to Toronto's development camp earlier this month, the defender revealed that he's receiving mentorship from current Leafs defensemen as well as some alumni like Mark Giordano. The 6-foot-2 Danford could make for an excellent fit for Canada should he make the team. He is responsible in his own end, and he demonstrated leadership capabilities when he was named captain of the Oshawa Generals ahead of the 2024-25 OHL season.

Raiders rookie WR showing he could be steal of 2025 draft
NFL

Raiders rookie WR showing he could be steal of 2025 draft

Las Vegas Raiders WR Dont'e Thornton Jr. is opening eyes at training camp, including QB Geno Smith, who appears to be trusting the rookie. Maybe that is the reason why general manager John Spytek has not looked for outside help at the position. And just maybe he got a steal from the 2025 NFL Draft. That looked evident on the first day of pads in Henderson, Nevada, where Thornton badly beat fellow rookie cornerback Darien Porter for a long touchdown, as described by The Athletic's Tashan Reed. In a piece, Reed said Thornton has been the first-string "X" receiver since OTAs and "could make an immediate impact." Thornton shared what Smith told him during training camp: "He tells me every single day, 'if you've got a one-on-one matchup, I'm coming to you,'" Smith said, as shared by Reed. "It means a lot to me. Being a rookie and just getting here ... just knowing that he believes in me a lot. It gives me a lot of motivation to keep getting better." While the headlines are more on rookie RB Ashton Jeanty for his potential big season, Thornton is making sure he is not forgotten after getting selected in the fourth round (108th overall) after leading the University of Tennessee with 661 receiving yards and six touchdowns. Listed at 6-foot-5 and 205 pounds, Thornton is getting all the opportunities he can get, given the Raiders didn't bother to add a veteran WR. One could see why Thornton is raising eyebrows in training camp. That is a good thing because Smith is trusting Thornton's potential playmaking abilities. Thornton is one of the tallest Raiders WRs besides Collin Johnson, and that could be a big deal given the Raiders need a big target minus TEs Brock Bowers, Michael Mayer and Ian Thomas. Yet, ESPN's Mike Clay is projecting Thornton to have a quiet year with 317 receiving yards and a TD. With such low numbers, maybe that is how the Raiders would prefer it to be, anyway. Only the Raiders know what they have in Thornton. It is up to Thornton to keep the momentum going into preseason games and beyond.

Bad News Brewers? Insider Gives Tigers-Eugenio Suárez Update
MLB

Bad News Brewers? Insider Gives Tigers-Eugenio Suárez Update

Are the Milwaukee Brewers still in the running for Eugenio Suárez? While it’s difficult to gauge the precise status of any Suárez-Brewers talks, one thing is clear — there are multiple contenders in hot pursuit of the Arizona Diamondbacks slugger. MLB.com’s Thomas Harrigan called Milwaukee the No. 2 landing spot for Suárez on Saturday (behind the Philadelphia Phillies) and also included the Seattle Mariners, Chicago Cubs, Cincinnati Reds, Detroit Tigers, and Houston Astros on his list. On Monday, USA Today’s Bob Nightengale provided an interesting update on the Tigers’ connection to Suárez. “The Detroit Tigers, one of the strong suitors for Diamondbacks All Star 3B Eugenio Suarez, would love to finalize a deal before Suarez leaves town Wednesday,” Nightengale wrote on Monday afternoon. “The DBacks are in Detroit for 3-game series.” Does Detroit, set to share physical proximity with Suárez over the next 72 hours, suddenly have the upper hand in the sweepstakes for the All-Star? That would be a wild development if so. Suárez and his suitors have become the leading topic amid what has otherwise been a quiet trade deadline, although analysts believe a flurry of moves will happen on Thursday with hours remaining before the literal deadline. Suárez’s recent production has only fueled the trade buzz. He’s hit 36 home runs this year and represents the most impactful bat on the market. Brewers fans are still split on whether acquiring Suárez would make a winning team better or possibly interrupt flawless chemistry. The only shocking outcome at this point would be if Suárez is still wearing a Diamondbacks uniform when August begins.

Insider provides notable update on where Commanders, Terry McLaurin stand on extension talks
NFL

Insider provides notable update on where Commanders, Terry McLaurin stand on extension talks

Terry McLaurin is entering the final year of his current contract and is not participating in team drills during training camp, as he is seeking an extension this offseason. With talks stalled, there has been speculation about how far apart the two sides are in negotiations. During an appearance on "The Pat McAfee Show," ESPN's NFL insider Adam Schefter reported that McLaurin is unlikely to accept less than DK Metcalf's new deal, which equates to $33 million annually, and likely "wants considerably more." In addition, the 29-year-old receiver and the Washington Commanders "don't seem close to a deal." With the regular season only six weeks away, it is a difficult spot for the Commanders, who are looking to build on what they accomplished last season. Quarterback Jayden Daniels is entering his second year in the NFL and needs his WR1 if he wants to take that next step in his development. Understandably, it seems Washington is hesitant to pay that much for an aging receiver, who will be 30 years old at the start of the season. Last season, McLaurin caught 82 passes for 1,096 yards and 13 touchdowns. However, these stats are somewhat underwhelming when considering that 552 of those receiving yards came in just five games. In the 12 games outside of those outlier performances, McLaurin totaled 544 receiving yards. Also, the 13 receiving touchdowns were a career high and the most for McLaurin since his rookie season (7). It was the first time in McLaurin's career when he had a star quarterback at the helm, which could be a point that last season was truly an outlier year for the veteran receiver. In addition, with Deebo Samuel in the fold, McLaurin's target share will inevitably suffer. Samuel will dominate targets in the screen game and short areas of the field, which McLaurin benefited from. McLaurin is an outstanding receiver, but the Commanders need to be smart in these negotiations. Paying $33 million for a player nearing the end of his prime is not good for team construction. Although Daniels is on his rookie contract for the next several years, overpaying for players does not necessarily lead to winning. If Washington can sign the seven-year veteran to a deal in the range of $25-27 million per year, that would be much more reasonable when considering the age and production of the player. The Commanders are in a tough spot with this transpiring this late in the offseason, but they should not pay a premium for McLaurin.

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!