x
Should The Maple Leafs Send McKenna To Team Canada?
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Maple Leafs are in the middle of an eight-game winless streak, and much of the conversation around the club has shifted to how it is handling its most important young player. With the 2027 World Junior Championship opening December 26 in Edmonton and Red Deer, Alberta, Toronto has an option worth considering: loaning 2026 first overall pick Gavin McKenna to Team Canada for the tournament.

Toronto blew a 3-0 lead Thursday and fell 4-3 in a shootout to the Kings. That stretched its winless run to eight games, with a 0-7-1 record. The Maple Leafs are 8-13-3. They sit 27th in the league standings and last in the Atlantic Division, already eight points back of the Eastern Conference’s second wild-card spot. Over the skid, Toronto has been outscored by 17 goals. Its power play has converted at 11.8%, its penalty kill sits at 57.9%, and its goaltending has a combined .868 save percentage. The summer moves have not yet produced the turnaround the organization was hoping for. Toronto now looks more like the 2025-26 team that wound up with the first overall pick at the draft.

McKenna has put up respectable production for an 18-year-old with six goals and 14 points through 24 games, though it comes with a minus-9 rating and just under 14 minutes of ice time per night. The bigger story has been how he’s being used. Head coach Jim Hiller benched McKenna for roughly half of an October 15 loss to Buffalo after the second period’s 10-minute mark, and he has cut his third-period minutes in games Toronto was protecting a lead. In a November 12 loss to Minnesota, McKenna played 8:07 at 5-on-5, the second-fewest on the team. He has yet to take a shift in 3-on-3 overtime this season. That includes Thursday’s loss, when Toronto had three strong chances to end it in the extra frame. Asked about it afterward, Hiller said, “He’s watched. We’ve had him up. And then called him off,” adding that overtime is a high-leverage situation that calls for “somebody who can make a play,” as reported by SportsnetCA reporter Sonny Sachdeva. Since the league began tracking ice time in 1997-98, there hasbeen 23 forwards drafted first overall that have debuted in the NHL, pointed out Daily Faceoff’s Matt Larkin. The only ones this century with lower TOI than McKenna are Alexis Lafreniere (2020-21) and Juraj Slafkovsky (2022-23).

Hiller has framed the rookie’s development around his complete game. He said in late October that McKenna “has to learn what an NHL player does typically” and said this month that he wants the 18-year-old to “be a good all-around player.” General manager John Chayka has backed his coach, describing McKenna’s deployment as “right down the fairway” compared with other recent top picks, per David Alter of The Hockey News. “You can’t microwave it,” Chayka said November 16, as reported by NHL writer Dave McCarthy. The production has dried up recently. McKenna has one goal and two assists in eight November games.

Questions about McKenna’s game aren’t new. His draft year was scrutinized heavily. A slow first half at Penn State, combined with Ivar Stenberg’s production against men in the SHL, led some scouts to question whether McKenna was the right pick at No. 1. The turning point came at last year’s World Juniors. McKenna had said the pucks simply weren’t going in for him at Penn State, and he put up four goals and 14 points in seven games for Canada. He finished second in tournament scoring and was named player of the game in the bronze-medal win over Finland. He then added 33 points over his final 19 games with the Nittany Lions to finish with 51 points in 35 games. The parallel is hard to ignore. Twelve months ago, the World Juniors gave McKenna the stage and the minutes to get back to his game, and his production afterward followed.

This year’s Canadian roster would give him a similar opportunity. Hockey Canada will name its 25-man roster in early December after a selection camp that opens December 13 in Calgary. Misha Donskov will coach the team, with Alan Millar serving as general manager. Canada plays in Group B with Czechia, Latvia, Norway and Switzerland. It opens against the Swiss on December 26 at Rogers Place, and the gold medal game is set for January 5. Here is the latest projection from The Athletic’s Scott Wheeler, released November 18:

Forwards: Caleb Desnoyers – Cole Reschny – Brady Martin; Tynan Lawrence – Caleb Malhotra – Jake O’Brien; Ryan Roobroeck – Maddox Schultz – Braeden Cootes; Ethan Belchetz – Jack Nesbitt – Dima Zhilkin

Defense: Carson Carels – Daxon Rudolph; Cameron Reid – Landon DuPont; Keaton Verhoeff – Ryan Lin

Goaltenders: Jack Ivankovic, William Lacelle

Extras: F Chase Harrington, D Xavier Villeneuve

Wheeler expects Matthew Schaefer, Michael Misa, McKenna and Ben Kindel to stay in the NHL. That leaves what he called “a by-committee Team Canada,” built on four lines and three pairs rather than a top-end star, although there is still some extremely high-end talent on the projected roster. The group’s strength is familiarity. Ten players in the projection won gold together at the 2025 U18 World Championship. In Wheeler’s view, Ivankovic, set for his third World Juniors, should be the tournament’s best goaltender. There are question marks up front. O’Brien missed the World Junior Summer Showcase with knee tendinitis and hasn’t played since a brief stint at Seattle’s training camp. If he can’t go, Wheeler expects Zhilkin or Cootes to move up, with a player like Lightning prospect Ethan Czata or Maple Leafs prospect Tyler Hopkins filling in on the bottom six.

What the roster lacks is a game-breaker, and that’s where McKenna fits. He made Canada’s team as a 16-year-old two years ago and was second in tournament scoring last year. In this lineup, he would likely play top-line minutes and run the top power-play unit, which is a significant change from his role in Toronto.

The move would, of course, carry real risk. Toronto plays a seven-game road trip from December 22 to January 7, and several of those games fall inside the tournament window. If McKenna attended camp, he would miss more. There is the injury risk that comes with any added games. There is also the optics of pulling a first overall pick out of the NHL lineup, which could be read as a step backward. Chayka has publicly backed the current plan, saying the organization is “really committed to doing the right thing for Gavin, both in the short term and the long term.”

It will be interesting to see how this unfolds in the coming weeks, even though the recent dialogue from the Leafs’ front office makes the McKenna loan seem rather unlikely. However, if they do send the Whitehorse native back to the tournament, they are allowing a young player to restore his confidence, be the star on the big stage in which he thrives, and reinvigorate the swagger in his game that all led up to him going first overall last June.

Image Credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect

This article first appeared on Pro Hockey Rumors and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!