
The New York Rangers paid a small fortune to acquire forward Pavel Dorofeyev from the Vegas Golden Knights this past summer, giving up Dallas’ 2026 first-round pick (26th overall), Buffalo’s 2026 third-round pick (92nd overall), and a top-10-protected 2028 first-round pick. It was a massive risk for the Rangers, but one they felt was worth it, given that the then-25-year-old was coming off a 37-goal season. Through 21 games this season, Dorofeyev’s offensive production has been okay, with six goals and six assists, but his plus/minus is an ugly -18, the worst in the NHL. Should Rangers fans be concerned about Dorofeyev’s play, and was the trade for him a good one? And was it wise to give him a seven-year deal worth $11MM annually before he ever donned the team’s jersey?
Make no mistake, the -18 is a concern, especially since his next-closest teammate, defenseman Braden Schneider, is at just -3. That is a sizeable gap, and it would probably be eye-popping to a casual observer. But plus/minus is a flawed stat, and it’s likely less of a concern than it seems. The bigger concern might actually be Dorofeyev’s offense, given that he is on pace for just 25 goals and 50 points, which would represent a significant drop from last year’s production in Vegas.
Clearly, Dorofeyev’s results haven’t matched what he or the Rangers hoped for at the start of the season, but some underlying numbers can be alarming or encouraging, depending on how you look at the glass of water. First, his 9.4% shooting is a career low by 4% and nearly half the rate he shot last season. It’s unlikely he will continue to perform at that level, which should encourage Rangers fans, as a regression to the mean would likely boost Dorofeyev’s goal-scoring. His 64 shots in 21 games are close to his pace in Vegas, so his goal-scoring should pick up if he follows the historical norms from his time with the Golden Knights.
That ugly plus/minus might make one wonder whether Dorofeyev is sacrificing the defensive side of his game in hopes of getting his offense going. But his underlying numbers suggest that isn’t the case. His defensive analytics and possession numbers look much like his last few years in Vegas, which is encouraging for Rangers fans. In fact, in New York, Dorofeyev is having a positive impact on his teammates’ possession numbers, just as he did in Vegas, with a +5.3 relative Corsi at even strength this year, compared to +5.6% last year and +4.2% in 2024-25 (as per MoneyPuck). His expected goals % at even strength is also remarkably similar to the last two years, sitting at 55% this season, compared to 56% in each of the last two years. The biggest difference in the analytics is on-ice goals %, which is at a low 35.7% this season, compared to 63.9% last year. That could be explained by Dorofeyev’s on-ice SV%, which sits at just 79.9% this season, down from 87.9% last year. Those numbers tell a story: early on, the Rangers aren’t getting saves when Dorofeyev is on the ice, which should regress to the mean over time.
At the end of the day, Dorofeyev still controls the play when he is on the ice. He continues to generate shots and chances and plays well defensively, but things just haven’t gone his way, and that happens in hockey sometimes. There is also the possibility that he may still be adjusting to a new team and city, which can take time when you’re playing with players you’re not used to. It’s probably not fair to question a seven-year contract after just 21 games, especially when most underlying data suggests this shouldn’t be a concern yet. But some folks might say Dorofeyev was a product of Vegas’ strong offensive environment and can’t cut it in New York. Maybe that will become true, but for now, he looks like the same player in a different uniform.
Whenever a team trades significant assets for a player and then hands them a mega deal, criticism follows if the player doesn’t live up to expectations. Right now, it’s fair for Rangers fans not to be happy with Dorofeyev’s first season in New York. But patience is required, and you never know what’s going on with a player, which makes his absence from Monday night’s game interesting, since Dorofeyev could be dealing with a nagging injury or something similar.
Rangers head coach Mike Sullivan also appears to be trying to find a place for Dorofeyev, rotating him into the lineup and testing him in different line combinations, which could make it harder for him to find traction. For now, I wouldn’t label the trade a failure or worry about it. Many factors are at play, and even a slump can make a good player look bad over a sample size as small as 21 games. Only time will tell whether the Rangers overpaid Vegas for Dorofeyev.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!