Should The Red Wings Trade Cam Talbot?

The Detroit Red Wings are in an interesting position leading up to the trade deadline. They sit third in the Atlantic Division but are only seven points away from the postseason cutoff entirely. Given their position, it’s unlikely that they’ll remove any pieces from their active roster, but would it make sense in the long run?

There’s no question: it’s John Gibson‘s net in Detroit. After a shaky start with the second franchise of his career, he’s been nearly unstoppable since December, posting an 18-5-1 record in 24 games with a .923 SV%. The team in front of him has been performing well, but it is difficult to argue that the Red Wings’ recent success is not primarily due to Gibson’s excellent play in goal.

That leaves veteran Cam Talbot in an awkward spot. Splitting the net at the beginning of the year, Talbot is now cemented as the team’s backup, playing in nine games since December, with one of those coming in relief. It comes one year after he received the majority of starts in Detroit, earning a 21-19-5 record in 47 games with a .900 SV% during the 2024-25 season.

Given their competitive nature and firmly being in playoff contention for the first time in a decade, it usually wouldn’t make sense for Detroit to reduce its roster. However, Talbot is one of the easiest netminders to move, given his lack of trade protection and relatively low salary. Coupled with the fact that the trade market for netminders is relatively thin, General Manager Steve Yzerman could capitalize in a big way.

His hypothetical market would be limited, but there would be at least a few teams. The Carolina Hurricanes, Edmonton Oilers, and Vegas Golden Knights are competitive teams in need of goaltending reinforcements. It’s hard to envision Talbot becoming the starter for any of those teams, but he would at least provide some much-needed breathing room if something went wrong with their regular starters.

Detroit wouldn’t need a goaltender in return, either. They would gain the flexibility to add almost anything; either deepen their resources in some way or acquire additional assets for future trades.

Knocking on the door last year, Sebastian Cossa has completely knocked it down this season. In 26 games for the AHL’s Grand Rapids Griffins this season, Cossa, 23, owns a 20-4-2 record with a .928 SV% and 1.99 GAA, including four shutouts. His performance this season, in a vacuum, isn’t the only argument for promotion. He has a .913 SV% across 110 games at the AHL level, showing that he’s ready to some capacity.

If the Red Wings continue to use Gibson as they have, Cossa would be burdened with only seven or eight starts throughout Detroit’s last 24 games to finish the season. If Cossa is going to back up Gibson next season anyway, what more valuable experience could you give a young netminder than see a seasoned veteran like Gibson prepare for the postseason?

To be clear, this isn’t an argument that this should be the Red Wings’ only move at the deadline, or even a priority. Still, if there is a market for him, they’re in a unique position to acquire assets for someone they know won’t be on the team next season and remain competitive.