Anthony Stolarz’s willingness to deliver an unfiltered postgame rant about the Toronto Maple Leafs’ play didn’t last long in Toronto—and it seems the goaltender quickly learned why. After openly calling out defensive lapses, weak backchecking, and a lack of physicality, Stolarz has completely reversed course, trading candor for polished “team speak.”
Just days ago, after being run over in his crease for the umpteenth time, he was blunt:
“I mean, I’m not happy… I’m going to try and stand up for myself… Maybe we can take a page out of their book and start getting to the net… Enough’s enough, and we’ve kind of got to start picking it up here.” That wasn’t all he said, noting, “I mean, a lot of guys have been here for a while. Overtime, you can’t let someone beat you up the ice there & gets a clear-cut breakaway.”
The remarks raised eyebrows for their candor and, even though they were mostly accurate, Stolarz wasn’t shy about airing his issues in public. Many felt the netminder was right to feel how he felt, but wondered if he may have overstepped, bringing the issues out from inside the locker room.
Perhaps even stranger than the original comments were his follow-up remarks, a blatant lie about the team’s play in a loss to the New Jersey Devils on Tuesday night. His message couldn’t have been more different:
“It was a really good effort by the boys… I loved the effort tonight. Guys were battling… I thought we did a lot of good things tonight.”
The comments were wildly inaccurate, and that can only mean one of a few things. He’s either trying to do damage control or he’s being so sarcastic that he’s delivering the same messaging in a much different way. Either way, his comments on Tuesday night seem as problematic as, or even more so than, his initial remarks because they don’t accurately reflect how the team responded.
Former NHL Head coach Peter Laviolette may have hinted as to why Stolarz pivoted. He talked about bringing inside-the-room criticism into a market like Toronto, and how it creates unnecessary noise. Former Leafs goalie Andrew Raycroft echoed the sentiment, suggesting Stolarz quickly realized the stakes. “It’s hard to have accountability because everybody’s gotta look out for themselves… that stuff lingers in Toronto,” Raycroft said, hinting the goaltender won’t be calling anyone out publicly again.
What started as a fiery, honest critique has morphed into safe, team-approved remarks—classic evidence of a hand-slap behind the scenes. It shows how fragile the Maple Leafs might be and that Stolarz might be looking to remove some of the pressure he placed on himself to be lights out since he was holding the rest of his team to a public level of accountability.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!