
The Toronto Maple Leafs are in free fall, with no clear answers on how they can find their way out of the hole they have dug themselves into without significant changes.
It was already bad enough that the team dropped six straight games in regulation on home ice, but they have made things worse by falling 6-3 to the Chicago Blackhawks on Tuesday. The Leafs are now in a situation where they have to run the table the rest of the way in order to have some semblance of a shot at making the playoffs.
That isn’t to say the season is completely lost, but they are not doing themselves any favours with how they are playing and the lack of action to change things up. The Leafs Nation team came together to assess how things have gotten to this point and what can be done to turn things around. Without further delay, let’s get into the roundtable!
What do you think is the biggest contributing factor to the Leafs’ struggles?
Arun Srinivasan, managing editor: Sergei Bobrovsky would be the easy answer, but it’s the team’s lack of defensive structure, inability to defend the net-front and a complete collapse in net-front scenarios. Toronto’s aging defence corps rarely can get the puck up to its forwards, and while Bobrovsky has been awful, the team’s five-man defensive errors are being roundly overlooked. Jim Hiller is in over his head, and he’s a runner-up in this dubious category.
Alex Hobson, associate editor: I think from a deep-rooted perspective, it’s a mixture of Jim Hiller’s lack of creativity and the Leafs’ fall off on the back end. But, if we’re looking at it as results on paper and nothing else, it’s Sergei Bobrovsky. Hard to accomplish much when your $7 million goalie allows 3+ goals on a nightly basis.
Michael Mazzei, writer and social media coordinator: There are too many to list in this answer, but the defensive structure has to be up there as one of the biggest factors in why things have gone off the rails. Whether it be the schematics when defending off the rush, the poor coverage, or the lackadaisical effort on occasions, the way the Leafs play defensively is agonizing to watch right now.
Jeremy Tingly, writer: So far it’s been a mixed bag of subpar goaltending, defensive zone coverage, a head coach who gets in his own way, and injuries. Losing Kirill Marchenko hurt a lot more than people realize, and Sergei Bobrovsky 100% needs to be relegated to backing up Anthony Stolarz for the foreseeable future. Hiller playing Ryan Tverberg ahead of Gavin McKenna is to me, a fireable offense, but we’ll see how long his leash really is if this losing streak creeps closer to 10 games.
What can the Leafs do to get things back on track?
Srinivasan: They’ve showed some signs of it, at least in principle, by promoting Gavin McKenna to the top power play unit. Jim Hiller’s mismanagement of McKenna has been a major storyline, and allowing his offensive prodigy to cook will go a long way in finding an identity. Beyond that, the Maple Leafs need to simplify their defensive structure and start holding veteran defencemen accountable for rimming the pucks up the wall with no forward to collect it, during breakouts.
Hobson: Get Kirill Marchenko back would be a great start, but if having him back is all that this team needs to get back on track, that will say a lot about how the team is built. At bare minimum, change the lines up and injuries be damned, try to find a combination that doesn’t render your whole middle six useless.
Mazzei: A lot of things need to change, but the first one is altering the makeup of the lines in a big way. As good as the first and fourth lines have been, the middle six is a wasteland and a mishmash of players with no clear identity. Put players in position to succeed, and it will be a start. But as I said, this team needs more than just line changes to right the ship.
Tingly: The Leafs need to commit themselves to 60 minutes of effort. Auston Matthews called the team out after the Blackhawks loss, and it’s obvious his message was directed at a few players, who don’t seem to be giving it 100%, 100% of the time. Their defense isn’t good enough, and there needs to be at least two trades to bring in some speed, and defensive prowess on the back end. Hiller also needs to play McKenna on the second line, and stop getting in his own way playing b-level prospects ahead of him in the lineup just to prove a point.
Which player do you think needs to step up the most to right the ship?
Srinivasan: Sergei Bobrovsky is the easy answer, so in conjunction, I’ll add Chris Tanev to the list. Tanev has battled injuries throughout the year, and plays with his heart on the line, but he’s simply been nowhere close to shutdown form when he’s been healthy. Toronto is being cautious in how it deploys Tanev. When he’s healthy, he needs to find the qualities that made him such a reliable defensive presence for the vast majority of his career.
Hobson: I’d like to see much more from Sergei Bobrovsky. His performance so far this season has been among the worst of any Leafs goalie who has played this much (even more so than the worst of Vesa Toskala’s days), so asking him to step up and steal some games isn’t an unfair ask by any means.
Mazzei: There are too many to choose from, but Sergei Bobrovsky is at the top of the list. His start to the season was already shaky enough, and it has only gotten worse. Allowing at least three goals against in all but one start is unacceptable, and he has to step up his play or else the season is toast.
Tingly: While Matthews and Nylander have gamebreaking capabilities and can carry a team for a week or two at a time, to me, it’s Anthony Stolarz. He’s been the better of the two goaltenders this season, and if he can get hot, Hiller will have no choice but to ride him out. Stolarz to me is the most important player right now in blue and white.
Do you think Jim Hiller is the right coach for this team? Why or why not?
Srinivasan: No. The whiplash has been astonishing, but this seven-game losing streak has revealed that Hiller is a man in over his head. Hiller hasn’t provided any answers to questions about the defensive zone coverage, merely stating offensive zone time would be cure to Toronto’s numerous woes. He’s lost the plot, and his management of McKenna’s minutes to date suggests he’s ill-suited for a prolonged rebuild, if the Maple Leafs elect to change course this year.
Hobson: If you asked me three weeks ago, even after the horrible mismanaging of McKenna in that loss to the Sabres, I still would have said to have some patience. If you took my word for it at the time, you’d be free to disagree by now. He seems to be in way over his head with the state of the team with the current losing streak, and as much as I don’t want to call for his job so quickly into it, he doesn’t look like the kind of guy you’d believe in to take you on a deep run.
Mazzei: No. This man has terrible tactics, takes too long to make changes, and does not inspire much confidence on the bench with his demeanour. Combine that with the fact that he is misusing his players and coaches scared, and you have someone who is not cut out to be an NHL head coach. The sooner they move on from him, the better.
Tingly: Hard to fire a coach less than 25 games in, no? This is a tough one, but considering his relationship, or lack thereof with Nylander, how he’s handled his goaltenders, McKenna, and the lines in general, I wouldn’t be against it. Bruce Cassidy would be a great get. The fact Hiller doesn’t speak to his team after games kind of rubbed me the wrong way when a team is struggling, and they need some messaging.
Do you believe that the Leafs can still salvage the season, or is it already too late?
Srinivasan: It’s over. Toronto sports 1.6 percent playoff odds via MoneyPuck. I’d like to buy into the notion that Auston Matthews in top-8 form and Gavin McKenna’s brilliance can save the season. The math says otherwise. It’s over.
Hobson: It can be salvaged, but the longer they keep acting like this is just a bump in the road, the slimmer those odds get. They need to recognize that something here is rotten and the sooner they do, the sooner this team gets a much-needed kick in the pants.
Mazzei: It’s not completely impossible for the Leafs to save the season and get themselves back in the mix, but they are not doing themselves any favours by not making any significant changes. Until that does happen, this is only going to get worse.
Tingly: This season can be salvaged, it’s the middle of November. However, they need to get back to .500 by Christmas break, and in order to do that, there needs to be some significant changes, newfound chemistry, and somebody needs to make a save. Chayka has his hands full, and if he doesn’t get this season right, I’m very concerned Auston Matthews is leaving.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!