Time for the Maple Leafs Pull the Plug?

Originally posted on NHL Trade Talk | By Old Prof | Last updated Feb 26, 2026 10:42 AM ET

Some nights, you watch a team play and realize the math isn’t just bad — the vibe is bad too. That was the Maple Leafs tonight. First game back, big chance to reset, and they walk into Tampa and get pushed around by a team that knows exactly who it is. The final score was 4-2, but that made the Maple Leafs look better than they played.

Meanwhile, Toronto looks like a group still trying to convince itself the season isn’t slipping through their fingers.

You can only say “they needed that one” so many times before it stops meaning anything. And honestly? It feels like we’ve hit that point. The standings aren’t moving. The games are running out. The usual “well, if they win five of the next seven…” routine is starting to sound like wishful thinking instead of analysis.

Maybe It’s Time to Stop Pretending

At some point, you have to quit dressing up small positives like they’re signs of life. A third line buzzing doesn’t matter if the playoffs are drifting away. A winger on a heater doesn’t change the direction of the season. And this idea that the Maple Leafs can just grind their way back into it? It’s getting harder to sell by the day.

If the season really is slipping away, then maybe the smartest move isn’t pushing harder — it’s changing direction altogether.

Three Things the Maple Leafs Should Do If They Call the Season Over

First, they should move the expendable pieces now. There’s no point keeping middle-tier players just to finish a little closer to .500. If they have value today, and they are not in next season’s plans, move them. Don’t wait for their stock to drop.

Second, shift minutes toward the future rather than the present. If the playoffs aren’t happening, then stop worrying about protecting veterans’ pride. Give the next wave the tougher minutes, the matchups, the responsibility. Let them learn in real time.

Third, start building next year’s structure now. Not the roster — the structure. Systems, roles, usage patterns, expectations. This season might be fading, but the habits you set now carry over. A lost year doesn’t have to be a wasted one.

So… Now What?

If the Maple Leafs are going to pull the plug, they need to stop tiptoeing around it. No more “we’re close.” No more pretending that a nice stretch of hockey changes the bigger picture. The truth is simple: missing the playoffs isn’t the embarrassment. Pretending right up to the end that they weren’t going to miss — that’s the part that stings.

This isn’t about giving up. It’s about being honest. And if this season really is done, then the smartest thing they can do is stop fighting it and start fixing what comes next.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: