x
What would a Crosby trade to Edmonton look like?
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Edmonton Oilers have established themselves as legitimate Stanley Cup contenders with a 17-3-3 record, but could adding Sidney Crosby be the move that finally puts them over the top?

With the Pittsburgh Penguins struggling at 7-11-2, questions surrounding Crosby’s future have resurfaced. Recent reporting suggests Pittsburgh could be approaching a rebuild, potentially opening the door for its longtime captain to pursue another championship elsewhere.

While Crosby has consistently expressed his desire to remain in Pittsburgh, the possibility of joining Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl in Edmonton presents an intriguing hypothetical.

What Would a Crosby Trade to Edmonton Look Like?

Edmonton Oilers receive:

  • Sidney Crosby ($3 million retained)

Pittsburgh Penguins receive:

  • Isaac Howard
  • Beau Akey
  • 2028 first-round pick
  • 2027 second-round pick

With Pittsburgh retaining $3 million of Crosby’s $8.7 million salary-cap hit, Edmonton would acquire the 39-year-old centre at $5.7 million for the remainder of the season.

However, the Oilers would still need to clear significant cap space, potentially through a separate trade involving Jake Walman.

Why Would Edmonton Make This Trade?

For Edmonton, the motivation is straightforward: winning the Stanley Cup. Adding Crosby would give the Oilers three elite centres in McDavid, Draisaitl and Crosby, allowing head coach Mike Babcock to deploy three dangerous scoring lines.

Crosby’s defensive awareness, faceoff ability and championship experience would also provide another dimension to Edmonton’s forward group.

There’s also the appeal of Crosby potentially winning another Stanley Cup alongside McDavid in a Canadian market. The two have represented Canada internationally, and joining forces in Edmonton could create one of hockey’s most compelling championship stories.

Why Would Pittsburgh Consider Moving Crosby?

Trading Crosby would be an emotional decision for Pittsburgh, but the proposed return offers meaningful rebuilding assets. Howard provides offensive upside, while Akey gives the Penguins a promising right-shot defensive prospect. Adding a first-round selection and a second-round pick would further strengthen Pittsburgh’s future.

However, Crosby holds a full no-movement clause, meaning he would have to personally approve any trade. Josh Yohe’s recent reporting indicates Pittsburgh would accommodate Crosby if he requested a move.

Crosby has previously acknowledged that “anything can happen” when discussing championship opportunities, although those comments were about playoff unpredictability rather than his willingness to leave Pittsburgh.

Comparable Blockbuster Trades

There is precedent for franchise icons joining contenders late in their careers. In 2023, Patrick Kane waived his no-movement clause to leave Chicago for the New York Rangers. The Blackhawks received a conditional second-round pick, a fourth-round pick and a depth defenceman, with salary retention helping facilitate the deal.

Similarly, Claude Giroux joined the Florida Panthers in 2022 after spending his entire NHL career with Philadelphia. The Flyers received Owen Tippett, a first-round pick and a third-round pick, while retaining 50 percent of Giroux’s contract.

Both deals demonstrate how a veteran star’s trade protection and preferred destination can influence the return.

Could Crosby Actually End Up in Edmonton?

The likelihood remains low, particularly given Crosby’s loyalty to Pittsburgh and ongoing contract discussions.

However, if the Penguins commit to rebuilding and Crosby becomes open to leaving, Edmonton would be an intriguing destination.

For the Oilers, acquiring Crosby without sacrificing their established core could be the ultimate win-now move. The question is whether Crosby would consider one final championship pursuit alongside McDavid and Draisaitl.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!