
When John Chayka took over as Toronto Maple Leafs general manager in the off-season, he did a couple of things right off the bat that made sense to me. One was that he built a team to win in the playoffs, not just in the regular season. Of course, they’d have to get to the playoffs. But given the elite talent on the team, I thought that was a good possibility.
So he brought in a large number of responsible veterans who were experienced, physical, hard-working, and good culture players. They included Teddy Blueger, Brandon Duhaime, Nick Paul, Zack McEwen, and Colton Sissons.
Chayka believed that if he could create a solid bottom six that he could trust, it would give the team a strong foundation. That way, the elite players could work and score. They could wear the opposition down. They would give the top lines a rest. The players might not be able to tilt the scales offensively, but they could count on opponents’ mistakes and score the odd goal.
And after all the lack of depth that the team had during the past few seasons, it seemed like a very positive thing. However, the production has stayed low. And that’s no surprise. The line doesn’t generate pressure and secondary scoring. More often, it holds the fort, which is exactly what it was meant to do. It seldom tips the scales in Toronto’s favour.
What’s happened, at least right now, is that the Maple Leafs are struggling to control play five-on-five. A unit that breaks even starts to feel like it really isn’t doing its job, because the team so desperately needs secondary scoring. This is a team that has been shut out a couple of times already this season, but had gone a long time without ever being shut out.
In fact, the Maple Leafs went 252 straight games without being shut out, including the playoffs and the regular season. This season they’ve been shut out twice. Once by the Edmonton Oilers and another time by the New Jersey Devils.
It’s really hard to say if what we’re seeing right now is going to stay or if it’s going to improve. But it raises a question: Is it possible to have too many of the same kind of players? In this case, depth players. I appreciate the fact that these forwards have strengths. But they also have limitations. They compete, they hit, they’re physical. They don’t take nights off. Better yet, they don’t make big mistakes. And they’re useful on the penalty kill.
What none of them are, however, is a primary offensive driver. If you put three of them together on the same line, you get a line that’s very good defensively and not very good offensively. And they’re limited in the same way. They’re hardly complementary pieces because they all do the same thing. They’re built from the same template.
I’m not criticizing them. I like them as players, and they are doing the job that they’ve been asked to do, exactly as they’ve been asked to do it. It’s a question about whether they are the right collection. Do the Maple Leafs need a more balanced bottom six that mixes shutdown, physical styles with someone who can still create offence and has a chance to score?
Right now, the Maple Leafs don’t win. Their elite players aren’t scoring, and sometimes their depth players can’t cover for them.
Does Chayka’s original logic for putting the bottom six together still hold? Having trustworthy depth players who don’t make mistakes is huge. But the question now is whether stacking too many similar players together has limited what the bottom six can contribute to the team in most games.
But right now, as we watch the season unfold, the question is this: Do the Maple Leafs have too many of the same kind of players in the bottom six? That’s a question we may need to keep asking as we go through the rest of the season.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!