The jerseys for next week’s NHL All-Star Game have a "reverse retro" spin on the mid-1990s getup and have been extremely well-received. These are the best All-Star uniforms in…at least a decade? Maybe two decades?
But let’s go deeper and ask the Daily Faceoff Roundtable: Which All-Star Game jersey is the best of all-time, and why?
MATT LARKIN: Maybe we’ll all lean toward whichever getup brings about the most nostalgic feelings. I think back to sitting in my parents’ unfinished basement, watching last-minute injury replacement Mike Gartner bury four goals in the 1993 All-Star Game. The 1993 uniform was consistent with the scheme dating back to the 1980s: NHL shield colors, lots of stars, just a fun design honoring the league itself. Still my favorite despite the fact I love the latest ones.
On Feb. 6, 1993, Mike Gartner was named the MVP of the NHL All-Star Game. He had four goals and an assist in the Wales Conference's 16-6 win against the Campbell Conference, becoming the fourth player in All-Star Game history to score four goals.
— 90sHockeyTweets (@Hockey90s) February 6, 2021
Photo credit: Getty Images pic.twitter.com/EYYWaIxClO
THIS DATE IN 1993: @NYRangers forward Mike Gartner’s #NHLAllStar Weekend included winning the Fastest Skater competition and a 4-1—5 outing in the All-Star Game to earn MVP honors. #NHLStats pic.twitter.com/FbIpgm8VTR
— NHL Public Relations (@PR_NHL) February 6, 2021
STEVEN ELLIS: OK, I love this topic! I’ll be the first to admit the logo wasn’t very good, but the 2015 All-Star neon green look is one that will always stand out to me. Hard on the eyes a bit, sure, but give me as much neon as possible. I love brighter-colored uniforms, and growing up, I liked putting neon tape on my goalie pads to stand out. That’s why I love Dallas’ alternates — they’re bold. The design itself could have used work, like the random striping on the arms and, again, the logo was ugly. But I’m glad they got creative with the accent coloring.
The 2015 NHL All-Star game jerseys: pic.twitter.com/GxR8F7TRxx
— The Canadian Game (@ItsCanadasGame) January 9, 2015
NICK ALBERGA: Great topic. Just because the game was in Toronto (so I actually paid attention), I’ll go with the 2000 North America vs. the World jerseys. I can’t believe it’s been nearly a quarter-century. We’re getting old. For me, every time I see those units, the nostalgia of Mats Sundin, Dmitri Yushkevich, Curtis Joseph and others comes back. Much simpler times, and there was actual animosity in the league.
2000 @NHL All-Star Game uniforms were beauties! Broke out of the conventional sweater design templates while incorporating new touches like collared necklines. pic.twitter.com/2bfH5xOAE9
— GameplanCreativeCHI (@GameplanChicago) January 20, 2023
My jersey of the day is this jersey I bought at the 2000 @NHL All-Star Game in Toronto. This was the goalie jersey for the North American Team. It was the 50th NHL All-Star Game and the league retired @WayneGretzky’s 99 that day. pic.twitter.com/0SFoSxsA6o
— Peter Schwartz (@SchwartzSports) August 29, 2020
FRANK SERAVALLI: I think the correct answer here is the era you grew up watching the All-Star Game as a kid. So for me, my favorites are the teal and purple ones of the mid-’90s, when Owen Nolan called his shot in 1997. I was a kid then, and that was when the All-Star Game felt like it mattered. It’s a unique prism through which we can view the entire weekend — through the eyes of kids — and that’s a reminder for John Tortorella and others who bash it.
On Jan. 18, 1997, Mark Recchi was named MVP of the NHL All-Star Game as the East beat the West 11-7. Both he and Owen Nolan scored hat tricks in the game.
— 90sHockeyTweets (@Hockey90s) January 18, 2022
(Getty Images) pic.twitter.com/OF9Szlpzvb
January 18, 1997: Owen Nolan calls his shot at the All-Star Game.
— This Day In Sports Clips (@TDISportsClips) January 19, 2023
(Notice the FoxTrax glowing puck)
pic.twitter.com/5wQydkNlkO
MIKE MCKENNA: You’re dead on, Frank. For me, it was the 1988 All-Star Game in St. Louis. I was eight years old when the NHL’s best came to town. Those gorgeous orange and black jerseys were iconic. And someone came up with the brilliant idea to make a graphic of Wayne Gretzky facing off against Mario Lemieux. On a frozen Mississippi River. In front of the Gateway Arch. I’ve had the poster hanging somewhere in my house ever since.
PHT Time Machine: Looking back at the 1988 NHL All-Star Game in St. Louis #Blues https://t.co/m5s28rrYrd pic.twitter.com/8ScE2WlHKW
— Blues Report (@blues_fanly) January 24, 2020
1988 NHL All-Star Game at StLouis....Limited Edition signed print in my collection pic.twitter.com/Pb3Rm8wScv
— Andrew Castell (@ACHockeyHistory) December 14, 2022
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!