Who’s Eyeing Simon Benoit? Trade Rumors Heating Up

His contract is the real winner here. At $1.35 million through 2026-27, Benoit represents a low-risk, cost-effective addition. There’s no pressure to make him a regular, but he’s capable of being one. And, as the cap goes up, his value only grows.

Which Teams Makes Sense For Benoit?

As NHL insider Chris Johnston noted back at the start of February, interest in Benoit “actually goes back quite a ways.” It shouldn’t be surprising if it’s eventually learned that GM Brad Treliving had talks with several teams before and after the Olympic break.

As likely sellers, the Leafs are exploring deals, and if a team is willing to step up and make a solid offer for Benoit, Toronto may have to overlook the fact that they are a bit thin defensively. As a team on the outside looking in, should they not be playoff-bound, that’s probably not an issue.

Several insiders—including David Pagnotta, Johnston, and James Mirtle—have floated a few ideas. Benoit, like Logan Stanley of the Winnipeg Jets, will appeal to teams looking for size and grit. The Edmonton Oilers have been unofficially linked to both defensemen. Benoit would fit as an affordable, tough bottom-pair option, offering a Mattias Ekholm-lite presence. He doesn’t possess anywhere near the same all-around game as Ekholm, but there’s a potential fit there.

The Buffalo Sabres are rumored to be seeking a physical presence for their bottom pair. Matthew Fairbun of The Athletic writes:

“The Sabres could use another defenseman, preferably one with playoff experience who can play a physical and defensively reliable game. Kekalainen doesn’t need to break the bank, considering the Sabres are set up well for the future on defense. But if this team is going to hold up to the demands of a playoff push, more depth would be helpful.”

source – ‘Sabres trade targets: Logan Stanley and 9 other defensemen who could fit in Buffalo’ – Matthew Fairburn – The Athletic – 02-11-2026

Meanwhile, the Anaheim Ducks, where Benoit played from 2020-23, could welcome a reunion. The San Jose Sharks, Tampa Bay Lightning, and other teams tight to the salary cap might also be intrigued.

What Is Benoit Worth on the Trade Market?

The question becomes the ask from the Maple Leafs. It’s hard to judge what he’d be worth to another team, given his somewhat one-dimensional play, but very low cap hit. The Maple Leafs’ willingness to retain or take back a bad contract also changes the dynamic.

While no deal is imminent and nothing is finalized, the chatter is growing louder. Seeing as he’s not a pending UFA, he may not ultimately be moved. Still, Benoit’s name is expected to stay at the forefront of trade discussions as the NHL deadline approaches.