Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
With Willie Mays gone, who is baseball's greatest living player?
Former Texas Rangers pitcher Nolan Ryan in 2019. Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

With Willie Mays gone, who is baseball's greatest living player?

Before his death Tuesday, Willie Mays was widely viewed as Major League Baseball's greatest living player.

Mays hit 660 career home runs and had numerous iconic plays, including "The Catch" in Game 1 of the 1954 World Series, placing him among the game's best.

On Wednesday, the Boston Globe's Bob Ryan pondered this question:

With that in mind, here are our five picks: 

Sandy Koufax | Age: 88

Koufax is the only pitcher in MLB history to lead the league in wins, earned run average and strikeouts three times in his three Cy Young Award-winning seasons. For the final five years of his 12-year career, he was the best pitcher in baseball, posting a 1.95 ERA in 181 games (176 starts) from 1962-66.

As good as he was during the regular season, Koufax fortified his legacy with legendary postseason performances. In leading the Los Angeles Dodgers to World Series titles in 1963 and 1965, Koufax went 4-1 in five starts. In all, he had a 0.86 ERA, struck out 52 in 42 innings and allowed 33 runners in 155 at-bats.

On two days' rest during the 1965 World Series, Koufax led the Dodgers to a Game 7 win over the Twins with a second consecutive complete-game shutout.

Pete Rose | Age: 83

MLB's all-time hits leader with 4,256, Rose has on-field credentials that can't be ignored. But he'll always be inextricably linked to his betting scandal as Reds manager, which led to his ban from the league. However, Rose was among the game's greatest players before becoming persona non grata.

Batting leadoff for "The Big Red Machine," he was MVP in Cincinnati's seven-game World Series win over the Boston Red Sox in 1975. Like him or not, Rose is a huge part of baseball's history and one of the sport's greatest living retired icons.

Nolan Ryan | Age: 77

Ryan finished his 27-year MLB career with record-holding seven no-hitters and is the league's all-time strikeout king (5,714). 

Ryan's consistency and longevity stand out. From 1968-92, he never posted an ERA above 4.00, and he also led the league in strikeouts from 1987-1990, his age 40-43 years.

On Aug. 4, 1993, he cemented his tough-guy rep by pounding Robin Ventura of the Chicago White Sox.

Rickey Henderson | Age: 65

Most people point to Cy Young's win total (511) as baseball's most unbreakable record, and while you won't hear any arguments from us, another one we think likely will stand the test of time is Henderson's stolen base record. 

During a 25-year career in which he starred for the A's and New York Yankees, Henderson stole 1,406 bases, 468 more than Lou Brock, who ranks second. (The active player with the most stolen bases is the Mets' Starling Marte, 35, who has 350 through Tuesday's games.)

For his career, Henderson batted .279 and posted a .401 on-base percentage. He led the league in walks four times (1982-83, 1989, 1998). Per Baseball Reference, he scored a run 39 percent of the time he reached base, well above the MLB average (31 percent). 

Barry Bonds | Age: 59

Like Rose, Bonds has a legacy that is tricky to deal with, but if we're simply looking at what he achieved as a player, he might be baseball's greatest living player. 

Already on his way to a Hall of Fame career by the time he left the Pittsburgh Pirates in free agency in 1993 to join the San Francisco Giants, Bonds hit another stratosphere in the Bay Area.

But while he starred for the Giants, Bonds was dogged by stories he used performance-enhancing drugs. Arguably, he is the face of baseball's steroid era. 

For the Giants, Bonds hit a record 73 home runs in 2001 and posted the highest on-base percentage for a season in 2004 with an absurd .609. Of his 2,935 career hits, 49.1 percent went for extra bases. 

Eric Smithling

Eric Smithling is a writer based in New Orleans, LA, whose byline also appears on Athlon Sports. He has been with Yardbarker since September 2022, primarily covering the NFL and college football, but also the NBA, WNBA, men’s and women’s college basketball, NHL, tennis and golf. He holds a film studies degree from the University of New Orleans

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

White Sox release former All-Star pitcher
MLB

White Sox release former All-Star pitcher

The White Sox have released right-handers Noah Syndergaard and Penn Murfee. Syndergaard’s release was announced on Sunday, while Murfee’s MLB.com profile page indicates he was let go on Friday. Syndergaard signed a minor league deal with Chicago in late June, which marked his first contract with any team since he was released by the Guardians in August 2023. Despite some interest from teams during the 2023-24 offseason, Syndergaard ended up not pitching anywhere in 2024, so the Sox started him off with some rookie ball outings just to get acclimated back to game action before reporting to Triple-A Charlotte. Syndergaard had a 2.93 ERA over his 15 1/3 frames of Rookie League work, but then was hit hard for a 10.13 ERA over two outings and eight innings at the Triple-A level. The ugly numbers in Charlotte included only two strikeouts and a rather incredible five homers allowed. While eight innings is obviously a small sample size, it was enough for the White Sox to decide to move on from Syndergaard, putting the former All-Star at yet another career crossroads. Syndergaard turns 33 later this month, and it is fair to wonder if retirement could be a possibility. Despite his past pedigree, the amount of time it took for him to land even a minor league contract could indicate that evaluators simply doubt he can ever regain any of his past effectiveness. A frontline member of the Mets’ pitching staff during his prime years, Syndergaard has never really recovered from a Tommy John surgery that sidelined him for virtually all of the 2020-21 season. He pitched decently well in posting a 3.94 ERA over 134 2/3 innings for the Angels and Phillies in 2022, but rather than approach his old form or at least settle in at a mid-rotation arm, Syndergaard regressed in the form of a 6.50 ERA in 88 2/3 frames with the Dodgers and Guardians in 2023. Murfee is another pitcher whose career was interrupted by a major arm injury. After posting a 2.70 ERA for the Mariners in his first 83 1/3 career big league innings, he underwent UCL surgery in June 2023, and some elbow discomfort kept him from making his return late in the 2024 season as a member of the Astros. The White Sox claimed Murfee off waivers from Houston last November, marking the fourth time in a 13-month period that the right-hander had changed teams on the waiver wire. Murfee made his return to the Show in the form of 12 2/3 innings of 7.82 ball for the White Sox earlier this season. Chicago outrighted the hurler to Triple-A in early May, and while Murfee had a respectable 4.09 ERA over 22 innings for Charlotte, he has recorded more walks (18) than strikeouts (16).

Justin Fields Called 'Biggest Loser' In Jets Training Camp
NFL

Justin Fields Called 'Biggest Loser' In Jets Training Camp

The New York Jets opted to cut Aaron Rodgers and sign Justin Fields to replace him during the offseason. This kind of commitment to Fields should bolster his confidence, but it could also place a lot of pressure on his shoulders. To this point, Fields has looked solid in training camp, aside from a scary toe injury that was quickly resolved in July. Justin Fried of the Jet Press recently reported that Fields' training camp may have reached a new low over the weekend as the young signal caller struggled. "Justin Fields put together his best practice of the summer to this point on Friday, completing his first 12 passes en route to an excellent all-around performance. The same can't be said about his showing on Saturday, however," Fried wrote. "Fields finished the day an abysmal 2-of-10 in the air, including a drop from rookie tight end Mason Taylor. "Some of his incompletions were catchable balls, but the Jets' passing game struggles on Saturday can largely be blamed on No. 7. Fields did flash his running ability with a 25-yard rushing score on the first play of red-zone drills, but the Jets would like to see more consistency in the air from the starting quarterback. Saturday's scrimmage was far from his best showing of the summer." Fields is a runner first at the NFL level, but his arm is nothing to scoff at. For most of training camp, his arm talent has been better than advertised, but during Saturday's scrimmage, it just wasn't there. A 2 for 10 performance is unacceptable for a $40 million quarterback who was signed to take over the team. The running game should open up the passing game for the Jets, which is going to need to be the case if Fields is going to struggle like this. However, it's just one day of camp. It's nothing to be too concerned about. Just because Fields lost this specific practice doesn't mean he's heading in the wrong direction as a whole.

25-time Grammy winner's sports agency blasts Jerry Jones for 'comical' comment
NFL

25-time Grammy winner's sports agency blasts Jerry Jones for 'comical' comment

The Dallas Cowboys may have 99 problems, and the way owner Jerry Jones handles contract negotiations could be considered a big one. Jones spoke with the media Saturday regarding Micah Parsons' contract situation. The EDGE, who is entering the final year of his rookie deal, has requested a trade. The 82-year-old owner clarified the Cowboys have no plans to trade Parsons. While discussing negotiations, Jones took an unprovoked jab at former Cowboys wide receiver Dez Bryant and his agent, rapper Jay-Z. "When we have a problem within the team and a player, I don't ever find the agent. He's nowhere to be found," Jones said. "...Jay-Z and I negotiated [Bryant's contract in 2015], spent hours. He said, 'Anybody in my organization is on time.' He said, 'My office used to be on the street corner, and I've always been early. So, they will be on time.' And I said, 'Where do I sign? But I'm going to call you.' Finally, he quit taking my call." The 25-time Grammy winner's sports agency, Roc Nation, took issue with Jones' comment. In a statement released on X Sunday, it denied his claim, calling it "comical." This is yet another example of Jones prioritizing attention when he should be focused on extending two-time first-team All-Pro Parsons. The Cowboys often delay deals for their stars. The team signed Bryant to a five-year, $70M deal in July 2015, just before the deadline to extend players with a franchise tag. Last season, Dallas signed quarterback Dak Prescott to a four-year, $240M contract ahead of its season opener against the Cleveland Browns. The team's procrastination often leaves it paying even more for star players and wastes valuable time. Parsons is still with the team at training camp in Oxnard, Calif., but isn't participating. He likely wants a contract that's similar to that of Pittsburgh Steelers EDGE T.J. Watt (three years, $123M). The pass-rusher is the highest-paid non-quarterback in the league. Jones' methods are one reason the Cowboys haven't won a Super Bowl since the 1995 season. Jay-Z should mention that if he wants to write a single that includes a lyric about the owner.

Troubling update emerges about Joel Embiid’s health
NBA

Troubling update emerges about Joel Embiid’s health

Joel Embiid’s trust in the healing process may not be paying off. A concerning update emerged over the weekend about the health of the Philadelphia 76ers star center. Brett Siegel of ClutchPoints reports that there is “genuine concern” around the league about the health of Embiid’s knee. Siegel adds that Philadelphia’s camp is attempting to downplay the concerns but notes that “word is bad” about Embiid’s health around the rest of the NBA. Now 31, the former MVP Embiid is still dealing with the ill effects of a torn left meniscus suffered during a 76ers game in February 2024. Embiid, who previously tore the same left meniscus back in 2017, quickly underwent surgery on the knee and missed two months. It appeared that everything was peaches and cream for Embiid after he returned to finish out the 2023-24 NBA season and even played at the 2024 Paris Olympics last summer as the starting center for Team USA. But Embiid missed significant time while managing his left knee throughout the 2024-25 season and even suggested at one point that he would need to have another surgery. In the end, Embiid appeared in just 19 total games for the 76ers last season and was shut down in February with the team nowhere close to contention. There was some talk a few months ago that Embiid might be undergoing the Kobe Bryant treatment to address the troublesome knee, but it looks like Embiid still hasn’t found a course of treatment that his knee is responding to. We know that the 76ers were already growing frustrated with Embiid’s lack of availability going back to last season. Now they may have to prepare for the potential of Embiid missing more time in 2025-26, a disastrous possibility given that they still owe the seven-footer an absurd $187.6M over the next three seasons.