Yardbarker
x
Assessing the 'Groundhog Day' division of NHL's non-playoff teams
Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby. Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Deja vu all over again: Assessing the 'Groundhog Day' division of NHL's non-playoff teams

Hope springs eternal in the summer for NHL fans who haven't watched their team play since early April. 

Could 2024-25 be the season that non-playoff teams from 2023-24 make the postseason? 

In a four-part series, we examine the non-playoff teams from last season and whether they have improved enough to give their fans hope they'll play beyond early April. 

We've put the 16 teams in four tiers — the "Long National Nightmare" division," "Groundhog Day" division," "Scratch-off" division" and our bottom tier, the "Puh-leeze" division.

Here's an assessment of teams in the second tier from the top, the "Groundhog Day Division."

In this division, it feels a bit like the classic Bill Murray movie, "Groundhog Day." How could this possibly be happening again? How much longer could this possibly last? What's the secret to ending this purgatory? For these teams, the playoffs are a possibility.  

8. Philadelphia Flyers | 38-33-11, 87 points, 21st

The biggest Flyers decision involved buying out the final season of struggling winger Cam Atkinson's contract. 

Otherwise, Philadelphia brought one of the best players outside of North America stateside, Matvei Michkov, a Russian forward. Arguably the best player not playing in the NHL last season, he was released by his KHL club, allowing him to arrive in Philadelphia much earlier than anticipated. The Flyers selected Michkov seventh overall at the 2023 NHL Draft.

For the Flyers, who have missed the playoffs in four consecutive seasons, Michkov is the only blue-chip prospect they have to show for multiple years of futility. 

The Flyers have weak depth at center and questions in goal, which are issues that could prevent them from returning to the postseason for the first time since the 2019-20 season.

7. Pittsburgh Penguins | 38-32-12, 88 points, 19th

Longtime center Jeff Carter retired after a difficult final season, and the Penguins allowed several fringe players to walk, including once-highly touted defense prospect Pierre-Olivier Joseph. Journeyman defender Matthew Grzelcyk joining Pittsburgh is an upgrade. 

The Penguins are banking on a different mix in their depth in dealing winger Reilly Smith, who struggled to score. They added center Blake Lizotte and winger Anthony Beauvillier in free agency and traded for centers Kevin Hayes from St. Louis and Cody Glass from Nashville.

Glass is a former sixth overall draft pick who has had an up-and-down career. Hayes has struggled to find his game for a few seasons now, but he offers experience as a big forward who can play on both special teams units.

Pittsburgh is hoping these small gambles hit before its veteran core, which includes 37-year-old Sidney Crosby, becomes a burden.

6. Seattle Kraken | 34-35-13, 81 points, 25th

Seattle had a difficult time scoring last season, finishing 28th as a team in five-on-five goals and 24th in high-danger chances created per 60 minutes, according to Natural Stat Trick.

In the offseason, Seattle invested heavily in offense. It hopes to get contributions from 2021 fourth overall pick Shane Wright, a center, and free-agent forward Chandler Stephenson. The best addition, though, is defenseman Brandon Montour, who the Kraken hope will spark a middling power play

Seattle paid big money to Stephenson and Montour in the hopes that they'd help improve the team immediately. If those signings don't pan out, Seattle could be in purgatory for a while.  

5. Detroit Red Wings | 41-32-9, 91 points, 18th

After making the playoffs for 25 consecutive seasons, the Red Wings have missed the postseason for eight straight seasons. Last season, Detroit seemed primed to end that streak, but it limped to an 8-12-3 finish and missed the postseason.

In addition to re-signing winger Patrick Kane in the offseason, the Wings added longtime scoring winger Vladimir Tarasenko to replace Vancouver-bound Daniel Sprong. They also signed depth forwards Tyler Motte and William Lagesson, replaced defenseman Shayne Gostisbehere with a similar player in Erik Gustafsson and added goalie depth in veterans Cam Talbot and Jack Campbell — both of whom are likely to see action this season. 

Additionally, Detroit dealt defenseman Jake Walman to San Jose — a move that caught some by surprise — to clear a roster spot for top defensive prospect Simon Edvinsson.

The question for Detroit is whether it actually goes anywhere with these moves. It feels like the Wings hopped on the treadmill. 

Next up: The Long National Nightmare Division

Alex Wiederspiel

Alex Wiederspiel is a digital reporter, play-by-play broadcaster, radio show host and podcast host in West Virginia covering high school athletics, Division II college athletics, and some West Virginia University athletics. He's an avid follower of all things hockey and football with a soft spot for prospects -- the future stars of the league. When not consuming sports, Alex is usually doing something related to Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, or watching movies for his movie podcast, The Movie Spiel

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!