Designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton might not be the MVP-caliber player he was in 2017, but as the Yankees eye October, his impact remains undeniable.
While his overall numbers in 2024 have been average, they tell a different story when you look closer at the situations that matter most—late innings, high-leverage moments and games the Yankees win.
Stanton has played 105 games this season, right around his totals from the last two years. Injuries, particularly to his lower body and hamstrings, have become a recurring issue, limiting his time in the lineup and leaving many fans frustrated.
However, when Stanton is healthy and slotted into the fifth spot, he’s still a threat. He’s hit 18 homers with an .848 OPS from that position.
In games the Yankees win, Stanton’s impact is significant: 21 home runs and an .862 OPS. Compare that to a meager four homers and .601 OPS in losses, and it’s clear the team needs him performing to succeed.
Interestingly, despite his injury struggles, Stanton's power remains undiminished when he connects. He’s in the 100th percentile for bat speed, ranked No. 1 in the majors, according to Baseball Savant.
There's power... then there is Giancarlo Stanton power
— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) June 13, 2024
449 ft. HR!!
(via @MLB)pic.twitter.com/5ydCDkfHON
That kind of power makes him a constant threat. Stanton’s contact is inconsistent, ranking in the 8th percentile for whiff %, but when he connects, the results are jaw-dropping.
That kind of power from the middle of the order gives New York depth and flexibility, especially when you look at how the rest of the lineup shakes out. With Gleyber Torres leading off, Juan Soto and Aaron Judge in the two and three spots, and Austin Wells right before Stanton, the Yankees have a lineup built to compete with anyone in October.
Soto and Judge are both having MVP-level seasons, while Wells has been consistent in the cleanup role with an .838 OPS.
As of Tuesday's win in Seattle, the Yankees now sit at 88-63, extending their lead over Baltimore to four games in the AL East. Their magic number to clinch a postseason berth is just one.
Stanton’s contributions, even in a somewhat diminished role, are a big reason why the Yankees are on the cusp of October baseball again.
But it’s not just about the regular season numbers. Stanton’s postseason resume speaks for itself.
In 27 career playoff games, he’s slugged 11 home runs and posted a .963 OPS. That kind of production, combined with Judge and Soto, gives New York a deadly trio for opposing pitchers.
“He’s huge in the middle...G doing G things. Not many people hit the ball like that,” manager Aaron Boone told the New York Post's Mollie Walker in August.
Stanton has shown he can still rise to the occasion. His 10 home runs from the seventh inning on and solid .814 OPS in late innings are proof that he thrives when the pressure is on. In high-leverage situations, his .737 OPS isn’t elite, but it’s enough to show he can come through when it counts.
The Yankees’ success this postseason will depend on more than just Stanton’s power, but having him healthy and productive in key moments could be the difference between a deep October run and an early exit.
As the team prepares for the stretch run, Stanton is far from a liability—he’s still the kind of game-changer that can flip the script in New York’s favor.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!