No. 12 Michigan survived an upset bid from Big Ten foes Minnesota on Saturday. The 27-24 margin was a tight follow-up to the Wolverine's big Week 4 win over then-No. 11 USC.
However, the Gophers were close to having a decent attempt for at least the game-tying field goal with under two minutes to play.
Minnesota successfully recovered an onside kick that ricocheted through Michigan players and would have put the Gophers near the Wolverines' 35-yard line. A flag for offside was thrown and the recovery was negated.
MINNESOTA RECOVERS THE ONSIDE KICK BUT A FLAG IS CALLED pic.twitter.com/d8PUckrczb
— FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) September 28, 2024
The officials determined Minnesota's onside kick-recovering players were past the kickoff line — the spot where the ball was teed up — before the kicker had made contact with the ball.
But upon the broadcast examining the replay, it was very difficult to see what players exactly the officials thought were offside.
Holy mackeral, the refs just bailed out Michigan BIG TIME after Minnesota recovered an onside kick with a chance to tie or win. pic.twitter.com/ZJ9WS6jjul
— College Sports Only (@CollegeSportsO) September 28, 2024
When paused at the moment of contact from the kicker, the nearest Minnesota player at the top of the field is still behind or at the very least equal to the kickoff line - which should be considered onside.
"[The official] said he broke the plane," Minnesota head coach P.J. Fleck said postgame of the explanation provided to him on the call. "Those were the words that were used, he broke the plane."
That kind of penalty is not reviewable nor able to be challenged by a coach.
It was a heartbreaking way for Minnesota's comeback bid to end, with Michigan able to knee out the remaining 90 seconds and move to 4-1 on the season.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!