Yardbarker
x
NASCAR has itself to blame for officiating controversies
NASCAR Cup Series driver Christopher Bell. Jim Dedmon-Imagn Images

NASCAR only has itself to blame for playoff officiating controversies

On Sept. 7, 2013, the NASCAR world was rocked by the "Spingate" controversy, in which Michael Waltrip Racing drivers Clint Bowyer and Brian Vickers intentionally manipulated the Federated Auto Parts 400 at Richmond to ensure that Martin Truex Jr. would make the Chase for the Sprint Cup. 

At the time — and up until Sunday morning — the scandal was seen as perhaps the worst scandal in NASCAR history. Small incidents of race manipulation by teams weren't uncommon, but Michael Waltrip Racing obliterated the definition of what it meant to skew the results of a NASCAR race. 

Eleven years later, another Virginia short track may have stolen the title of NASCAR's most egregious instance of race manipulation. 

In the closing laps of Sunday's Xfinity 500 at Martinsville, Christopher Bell and William Byron were battling for the final spot in the Championship Four. Byron held a one-point advantage over Bell — who was trapped a lap down and was unable to gain any positions — though Byron was quickly falling through the field. 

In the final corner, however, Bell made his final pass of the night on Bubba Wallace, tying him with Byron in the points. Due to Bell having the tiebreaker necessary to leap over Byron for the final transfer spot, Bell was in the Championship Four via the slimmest of margins. 

However, Bell had ridden the wall from the middle of turn three to the exit of turn four, and after a long deliberation by NASCAR officials, his move was deemed a safety violation, which penalized Bell and knocked him out of the Championship Four.

 Just like that, Byron was back in. 

Questions had already arisen regarding race manipulation for both drivers. Bell's move was out there in the open, but soon it seemed obvious that Wallace — who like Bell, drives a Toyota — had intentionally backed off in order to give Bell the position. 

At the same time, radio communication from the No. 1 team of Ross Chastain and the No. 3 team of Austin Dillon — both Chevrolet teams like Byron — made it clear that Dillon and Chastain were instructed to not pass Byron and to hold off the cars behind them that could knock Byron out of the Championship Four.

NASCAR's decision to put Byron in the Championship Four over Bell was immediately met with outcry from Bell's car owner in Joe Gibbs, who was told the team wouldn't be able to appeal the move.

 Before you start feeling bad for NASCAR for having to make a tough decision in a crucial race, remember that they created this monster. 

Without NASCAR's Chase format that was present in 2013, Spingate wouldn't happen. Without the playoff format, Kevin Harvick doesn't intentionally wreck the field at Talladega in 2015, or intentionally spin Kyle Busch at Martinsville in 2020. Without the current playoff format, Dillon doesn't intentionally wreck Denny Hamlin and Joey Logano on the final corner at Richmond. 

And without NASCAR's current playoff format, Bell doesn't feel the need to ride the fence in turns three and four. Chastain and Dillon don't block for Byron. Wallace doesn't have to show off his acting chops in post-race interviews.

Most importantly, NASCAR isn't faced with the public relations black eye of race manipulation the week before it crowns its champion. 

There's a litany of competitive reasons why NASCAR doesn't need a playoff format in order to be exciting, but Sunday proved another reason why — it creates opportunities for the integrity of the sport to crumble in what should be its most exciting moments. 

Samuel Stubbs

Hailing from the same neck of the woods as NASCAR Hall of Famer Mark Martin, Samuel has been covering NASCAR for Yardbarker since February 2024. He has been a member of the National Motorsports Press Association (NMPA) since October of 2024. When he’s not writing about racing, Samuel covers Arkansas Razorback basketball for Yardbarker

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!