Conventional wisdom in the NFL is that if you have a franchise quarterback playing at an MVP level, you are probably going to have a real chance to win the Super Bowl.
The Cincinnati Bengals are throwing that conventional wisdom in the trash can this season.
With their 44-38 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers on Sunday, the Bengals fell to 4-8 and probably eliminated themselves from realistic playoff contention.
It is bitterly disappointing for two reasons.
The first is that the Bengals entered this season with Super Bowl expectations, thanks to the return of a healthy Joe Burrow for a full season.
The second is that Burrow has not only come back, he has played at an MVP level, and the Bengals have completely wasted it. Sunday's game was no exception.
Burrow completed 28-of-38 passes for 309 yards and three touchdowns while also helping the Bengals offense score 31 points (the other seven Bengals points came on a defensive touchdown). It still was not enough to win.
It is already the fourth time this season the Bengals scored at least 33 points in a game and lost. They have two additional games with at least 25 points and lost.
The rest of the NFL has just one loss season when scoring at least 33 points in a game (which, oddly enough, came against the Bengals).
The Bengals are 2-4 when scoring 33 or more this season pic.twitter.com/B0HtY8B1XO
— NFL on CBS (@NFLonCBS) December 1, 2024
The culprit? A defense that has been one of the worst in football that seems to be getting progressively worse every week. On Sunday, they allowed Russell Wilson and the Pittsburgh Steelers offense to do whatever they wanted all day.
Where this gets concerning for the Bengals is that they had a two-year run in 2021 and 2022 where they made a Super Bowl and lost an AFC Championship Game. With a young franchise quarterback and stars all over the offense, they looked like a team that was set for more than a decade of dominance.
They have simply not been able to build on that and have taken huge steps backward the past two seasons. Burrow's absence for most of 2023 shielded the rest of the flaws from criticism. Now that Burrow is playing like an MVP and the team is even worse, it puts an even bigger microscope on the rest of the organization.
They did not adequately fix the defense; they have played hardball with star wide receivers Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins in contract negotiations, and now they are headed not only for another non-playoff season but also a likely losing season.
The Bengals went through a similar experience with Carson Palmer in the 2000s, where they had a top-tier quarterback, saw a brief flash of brilliance, and failed to build on it. Palmer eventually got tired of it, threatened to retire, and got his way out of Cincinnati.
It might happen again if they do not fix the rest of the team. Very soon.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!