Yardbarker
x
NFLPA report cards: Takeaways for the NFC East
Mike McCarthy. Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

NFLPA report cards: Takeaways for the NFC East

On Wednesday, the NFL Players Association released its third annual report cards for the league's 32 teams. Nearly 1,700 players shared with their union information about their team's facilities, treatment of their families and more.

Here are four surprising takeaways from the NFC East:

Dallas Cowboys: Mike McCarthy will be missed

The Cowboys finished 10th overall in the survey, jumping up two spots from the previous year. As in 2024, the team’s training room and training staff received low marks, but when asked what the team did best, the most consistent answer was the leadership and culture fostered by the former head coach.

Players believed McCarthy was highly receptive to locker-room feedback relative to the team’s needs, ranking him 11th among NFL coaches, and 97% of Cowboys players felt McCarthy was efficient with their time, ranking him 12th.

Fortunately, new head coach Brian Schottenheimer spent three years working under McCarthy as a coaching analyst and offensive coordinator, so expect the good vibes to continue next season.

New York Giants: John Mara takes a hit

New York came in at No. 20, which was no surprise given the team’s 3-14 record. The Giants’ strength coaches received high marks with an A- grade, but ownership appears to be a weak spot. Mara, CEO and co-owner of the New York Giants, earned an 8.8/10 rating and a B+ grade from the players last season but earned a C+ grade this year.

That could have something to do with how the team handled the contracts of former quarterback Daniel Jones and former running back Saquon Barkley, who carried rival Philadelphia to a Super Bowl championship with a record 2,504 yards (including in the playoffs) last season.

Jones threw for fewer yards in 10 games with the team last year after accepting a four-year, $160M contract from the team in 2023.

Philadelphia Eagles: Sweat the small stuff

Given the team’s recent success, it’s hard to believe Philadelphia ranked 22nd out of 32 teams. Fortunately, Eagles players offered three easy, low-cost solutions: provide childcare on game days as most NFL teams do, prioritize first-class seating for players rather than coaches and stagger lunch times in a cafeteria that’s often overcrowded with business staff.

On the bright side, Eagles players appear optimistic that things will improve. When asked what the team does best, they expressed that ownership typically listens to their feedback and prioritizes improvements. 

Washington Commanders: Space would help

After two straight last-place finishes, the Commanders finished 11th in this year’s survey thanks in large part to newcomer Dan Quinn, who finished the year as the NFLPA’s top-ranked head coach.

A 12-5 record and a trip to the NFC Championship game will do that but while many of Washington's on-the-field issues appear to be resolved, the same can’t be said for some of the team’s facilities.

Apparently, the team needs a new locker room with bigger lockers and more space as only 49% of players feel the locker-room size is adequate. Overall, the Commanders locker room ranked as the fourth-worst in the NFL but was the only area to receive a failing grade this year. 

Rest assured, once the team gets through the red tape of stadium construction, its locker room could be among the NFL’s best.

Bruce Ewing

Bruce Ewing is 183 pounds of twisted steel and Happy Meals. His work has appeared on Yardbarker, 5th Down Fantasy, Inside the Iggles and MSN. Give a Philly fan a break and follow him on Twitter/X at @fantasybruce.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!