Jorge Lopez’s recent suspension for throwing a pitch near Andrew McCutchen’s head is more than another blip in MLB’s disciplinary ledger. The latest chapter in a story reveals how poorly equipped the league still is at handling player mental health and emotional wellness.
Lopez has been in emotional freefall for some time. Last season with the Mets, he was visibly frustrated after giving up a key home run. In anguish, he tossed his glove into the stands and was ejected.
Jorge López has been ejected by third base umpire Ramon De Jesus.
— SNY (@SNYtv) May 29, 2024
López threw his glove into the crowd on his way off the field. pic.twitter.com/5BlF6badFQ
His postgame comments, muddled by a language barrier, painted him as a clubhouse malcontent until he clarified that he was criticizing himself, not the team. Days later, the Mets designated him for assignment.
I asked Jorge Lopez if he regretted throwing his glove into the stands. Not only did he say no, he then called the Mets “the worst team in the whole f—cking MLB.”
— Steve Gelbs (@SteveGelbs) May 30, 2024
I later gave him a chance to clarify and he confirmed that’s what he meant.pic.twitter.com/Io2Cqh3Bdj
That incident wasn’t just a player losing his cool. It was a red flag waving at full mast.
Now, with the Nationals, Lopez finds himself again in the spotlight for the wrong reasons. Whether intentional or not, his suspension for the pitch near McCutchen has reopened questions about his temperament.
Jorge López has received a three-game suspension and a fine for intentionally throwing at Andrew McCutchen last nightpic.twitter.com/hxeUwgd8rX
— B/R Walk-Off (@BRWalkoff) April 17, 2025
But empathy’s largely missing from the narrative—an understanding that this isn’t just about mechanics or discipline. It’s about a man under real strain.
Lopez’s personal life is no minor footnote. His son suffers from a serious illness that requires constant care. That kind of emotional weight doesn’t switch off in the bullpen. It travels with you — in your hotel room, on the mound, in every moment of silence between pitches. That background makes his recent behavior more understandable, even if not excusable.
So, where is MLB in all of this?
If Lopez were on the IL with a torn UCL, he’d have a medical team, rehab plan and daily check-ins. But for a player showing visible signs of emotional exhaustion and distress? There’s no standard operating procedure.
That has to change.
MLB needs a league-wide policy on compassionate intervention. This issue is not just about Mental Health Awareness Month optics but also infrastructure: full-time mental health professionals embedded with every team, emergency intervention protocols, and genuine support systems that treat emotional well-being with the same urgency as physical injury.
Players like Lopez shouldn’t have to implode before someone steps in publicly.
This is also an opportunity for teams to rethink their roles. The Nationals and other teams could take a more active approach to assessing emotional and psychological readiness, just like they do velocity and spin rate. Managers and front offices should feel empowered to step in and offer help, not just hand down consequences.
In the end, Jorge Lopez is not just another pitcher struggling with control. He’s a father under immense pressure, trying to hold it together in a sport that often values toughness over transparency.
MLB has a choice: continue punishing players like Lopez for breaking down or build them back up with compassion and care.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!