Before this season, the last postseason clash between the Toronto Maple Leafs and Ottawa Senators came in 2004, when the Leafs won a first-round series in seven games. So, naturally, there's a lot of pent-up emotions in this season's first-round series.
Game 1 Sunday in the "Battle of Ontario" did not disappoint.
The Maple Leafs won a penalty-fest in Toronto 6-2, leading Senators captain Brady Tkachuk to note in a post-game interview that Ottawa must "be more disciplined.”
Tkachuk was referring mostly to penalties. In the final 44 seconds of the third period alone, the teams were assessed 12 penalties — six to Ottawa and six to Toronto. One final roughing penalty was given to Ottawa at the end of the game.
Are these penalties an issue of discipline or is it the passion of playoff hockey?
Toronto got goals in the first period from Oliver Ekman-Larsson and Mitch Marner. Drake Batherson scored for Ottawa toward the end of the period.
It was Ottawa’s Tim Stützle who got the penalty party started in the second period against Toronto’s Chris Tanev with a boarding call. The Maple Leafs’ John Tavares scored about nine seconds into the power play. Less than two minutes later, Ridly Greig got called for a crosscheck to Tavares.
Originally, this was called as a major penalty. Greig’s stick was in Tavares’ neck as he followed through on the hit. After review, the referees reassessed the penalty as a two-minute minor.
Ridley Greig received a two-minute minor for cross-checking on this play on Tavares.
— BarDown (@BarDown) April 21, 2025
( ESPN) pic.twitter.com/kGJSQmLflh
That penalty ratcheted up tension between the teams, and the hits kept coming. A crosscheck from Adam Gaudette of the Senators to the Maple Leafs’ Auston Matthews led to another Toronto goal, this time from William Nylander.
The Senators would be called for two more penalties in the second, with the Maple Leafs adding two of their own.
The third period would see the Senators assessed three more penalties and one more to the Maple Leafs before things took a turn. The initial penalty started with a high stick by Nicholas Robertson of the Maple Leafs to the Senators’ Nikolas Matinpalo at the 19:16 mark. Ottawa's Matthew Highmore came to his teammates’ defense with a roughing penalty, and then a scrum resulted.
Twelve total penalties were called, and the referee had to read them all from a piece of paper.
A grocery list of penalties to end the game pic.twitter.com/4na7a4s0Ae
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) April 21, 2025
One final penalty was given to Nick Jensen at the end of the game for roughing. In total, the Senators had 15 penalties.
Fans expect the playoffs to be full of intensity. Players are going to bring passion to every game, and it’s going to lead to penalties. It’s the normal playoff hockey atmosphere.
However, the Senators cannot afford to take penalties like Greig’s against the more experienced Maple Leafs. The Senators haven’t been in the playoffs since 2017, and their younger players are hungry and eager to prove themselves. But players must be mindful about letting their emotions get in the way of playing well.
For Ottawa to make it to the second round, it must listen to its captain and be more disciplined.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!