Trevor Story's tenure with the Boston Red Sox has been suboptimal from the very start. If Boston's beat reporters are to be believed, that tenure might be nearing an end soon.
Questions arose almost immediately after Boston signed the shortstop to a six-year, $140M contract before the 2022 season. Boston appeared set at the position with Xander Bogaerts, and few understood what the front office was thinking in signing another shortstop. It also seemed particularly curious that the club hadn't instead approached Bogaerts about a contract extension.
Story slid over to second base in that first season in Boston but struggled mightily at the plate. He would miss more than a month due to a hand injury and was limited to appearing in just 94 games, which would prove to be the high-water mark of his Red Sox career.
Injuries have continued to plague Story since. That next spring, he underwent surgery to repair a tear in his UCL that would keep him off the field until August. Then last season, he fractured his shoulder in early April and was out nearly the entire season.
Through his first three seasons in Boston, Story failed to appear in more than 100 games. He hit a collective .232/.296/.397 (89 OPS+) in that stretch, with just 21 home runs.
MassLive's Chris Cotillo and Sean McAdam discussed Story on Tuesday's episode of the "Fenway Rundown" podcast. Cotillo's thoughts on Story's future were pointed:
"This is a guy who came out super hot. We were talking on this show about, will he opt out at the end of this season? I don't think he will. Will the Red Sox opt out I think is the bigger question.
"You hate to see a guy who's a good guy and a good clubhouse leader, someone you and I both really like, be in DFA territory."
Where do the Red Sox go from here with Trevor Story? Unpacking it on a new @FenwayRundown with @Sean_McAdam: pic.twitter.com/80DmXVcbQt
— Chris Cotillo (@ChrisCotillo) May 27, 2025
Cotillo was referring to an opt-out clause in Story's contract, which would allow the 32-year-old to forego the remaining two years on his contract and head into free agency. Such a decision seems extremely unlikely given how Story has performed with the Red Sox. He won't find a two-year, $50M deal on the open market from any team.
After going 0-for-4 on Tuesday, Story is now hitting .217/.264/.319 (66 OPS+) through 207 plate appearances. Just nine of his hits (three doubles, six home runs) have gone for extra bases, and he's struck out 66 times (the third-highest total in the majors).
Designating Story for assignment would surely signal the end to his Boston tenure and would likely be a precursor to his being released. A trade seems unlikely unless the Red Sox are willing to pay off nearly all of Story's remaining contract. The Sox might be better off moving on at this point, particularly since it would allow more opportunities for their young core (namely Kristian Campbell and Marcelo Mayer) to keep playing every day.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!