With the New York Knicks eliminated in the NBA’s Eastern Conference Finals by the Indiana Pacers on Saturday night, all eyes in the Big Apple will now focus squarely on Juan Soto's struggles or success with the New York Mets.
Whether you’re a New York Mets or New York Yankees fan, the Knicks’ season ending means the attention moves to Soto in his first season in Queens. If you’re a Mets fan, you’re hoping he lives up to his $765 million deal signed in the offseason. If you’re a Yankees fan, you’re hoping that he doesn’t, as it just proves (at least in your mind) that either he should’ve stayed in the Bronx for the rest of his career, or he’s not worth that much money, so good riddance.
Soto’s start to this season has provided plenty of fodder for New York talk shows and columnists, with everything from his slow start at the plate (with an OPS+ of 117 entering Saturday compared to his career average of 158) to his perceived lack of hustle drawing headlines and point-counterpoint arguments. However, even Soto took a back seat in New York in recent weeks as the Knicks advanced to their first conference finals appearance since 2000.
Now with the Knicks sidelined and the Jets and Giants still preparing for the NFL season ahead, baseball will become the biggest talking point in New York… with Soto and his play likely drawing the most comments.
Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns on Juan Soto:
— Anthony DiComo (@AnthonyDiComo) May 30, 2025
"Do I think he's trying to do a little bit too much right now? Yeah, I think he's probably trying to do a little bit too much right now. And that is natural for a player who cares."
Sure, the Yankees are on top of the American League East and Cody Bellinger and Paul Goldschmidt are doing just fine giving Aaron Judge some much-needed support in the lineup, but the biggest story in New York has been Soto since the Yankees’ 2024 season ended in the World Series. Storylines have pivoted from “Where will Soto sign?” to “Does he hate Judge?” to “What’s wrong with Soto?” … but every question has revolved around the 26-year-old superstar.
If Soto thought the lights of New York were bright last year, he’s learning quickly that New Yorkers will stand for a lot of things, but a lack of hustle coupled with a lack of production will earn you plenty of boos, jeers and unflattering headlines.
Saturday's home run against the Colorado Rockies certainly provided a bit of respite for Soto as he snapped a personal power outage, but more will need to be done to build upon it for Mets fans to believe he is living up to his end of the contract.
There it is: Juan Soto's first home run since May 9.
— Anthony DiComo (@AnthonyDiComo) May 31, 2025
Soto has reached base safely in four of his last six plate appearances. pic.twitter.com/OwOBm15NkE
Perhaps there was no bigger Knicks fan over the past few weeks than Soto as he settled into his spot in Queens. However, with baseball season now in full force in New York, Soto’s first summer with the Mets could indeed be a cruel one if his numbers don’t keep improving.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!