If the New York Yankees are going to stay in contention for a postseason berth, the issues that surfaced in the ninth inning of Saturday's 12-1 loss to the Boston Red Sox must be resolved.
Trailing 5-1 heading into the final frame at Yankee Stadium, the Red Sox jumped on reliever Paul Blackburn for seven runs to turn the game into a laugher and put Boston in position for a sweep of the four-game series on Sunday.
While the immediate reaction would be to point to Blackburn as the cause of New York's late struggles, a deeper look into the game reveals that the 31-year-old right-hander's teammates did little to help him escape from what became a 71-pitch outing.
Playing right field, Giancarlo Stanton became an easy target for the aggressive Red Sox, taking extra bases when possible against the lumbering slugger. Playing just his ninth game in the outfield this season, Stanton showed that, at this stage of his career, his legs aren't going to get him to base hits quickly.
Knowing Stanton would be slow to get to any kind of hit, Boston runners took advantage, including Trevor Story's ninth-inning single to right with Jarren Duran already on first base. With Stanton having to come up to field the ball, Duran didn't hesitate, going from first to third and beating Stanton's throw to the bag.
What the Yankees saw from Stanton on Saturday should be an immediate reminder and warning sign that his days o f doing anything productive outside of hitting are likely past him.
Another problem in the ninth was a wild overthrow from Anthony Volpe on David Hamilton's grounder. While Volpe's throw went way over the head of first baseman Ben Rice, a closer look at the replay showed that Volpe hesitated and might have had a play at second base had Jazz Chisholm Jr. been covering the base.
Red Sox are completely embarrassing the Yankees pic.twitter.com/mV4F2YDH99
— Talkin’ Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) August 23, 2025
The loss was the third consecutive win by the Red Sox in the Bronx, a problem in and of itself for a Yankees team that is battling with Boston in the American League wild-card race.
Aaron Boone was asked if he thinks the Yankees are "running out of time" to get themselves on track against teams above .500:
— Yankees Videos (@snyyankees) August 23, 2025
"No, we're not running out of time, but if we don't do better, then it's going to fizzle out and we're not going to get to where we want to be." pic.twitter.com/pbvyw4tATQ
But the bigger problems are the optics of that ninth inning as well. With Yankees fans already frustrated with manager Aaron Boone, watching their arch-rival play fundamentally sound baseball while the Yankees botch the small things that become big innings will only make the temperature rise in the Bronx.
"Volpe made an error, his first one in a few weeks. Been playing really well out there. Bad throw, and then not communicating well enough with a new player on the 3-2 count where Benny's playing behind him."
— Yankees Videos (@snyyankees) August 23, 2025
Aaron Boone talks about the Yankees' 9th inning miscues: pic.twitter.com/fPyqcQ6Nrt
While Yankees batters may have hit an MLB-leading 210 home runs this season entering Saturday's action, it's not just about the long ball. As Saturday showed, if New York can't do the little things right, not even the big hits may be able to keep the Yankees alive in the postseason hunt.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!