Blue Jays pitcher's first career trip to IL comes at inconvenient time for Toronto

What does Jose Berrios' injury mean for the Blue Jays?

Given his recent downturn in results and move to the bullpen, he had become less important to Toronto’s pitching staff. Once the playoffs arrive, all teams will rely more on their top arms, making the length a bit less important. The Jays have already clinched a spot but are still trying to lock down the division and a first-round bye or home-field advantage in the wild-card round.

Still, it’s the latest in a series of recent cuts to Toronto’s depth. Chris Bassitt also went on the IL recently, in his case due to a back injury. That leaves the Jays with a rotation mix consisting of Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber, Max Scherzer and Trey Yesavage. Gausman and Bieber give the Jays a strong one-two punch for the playoffs but Scherzer has been awful of late, with 25 earned runs allowed in his past 25 innings. Yesavage was just promoted and has just two major league starts under his belt. Eric Lauer had a good run in the rotation earlier this year but was moved to the bullpen after Bieber got up to speed. All of Lauer’s appearances in the past three weeks have been less than two innings.

That’s a less-than-ideal situation for the club in the short term. If this ends up being a long-term injury, that would also be notable for the Blue Jays. They are about to lose Bassitt and Scherzer to free agency. Bieber has a $16M player option but will surely go for the $4M buyout if he finishes the year healthy.

Although Berríos has been limping through the second half, the Jays were surely planning on installing him back into the rotation next year alongside Gausman, Yesavage and perhaps Lauer. The Jays were presumably already planning to pursue starting pitching this winter and that desire should only increase if Berríos ends up slated to miss part of next season.

Down the line, that could also impact him personally. Berríos can opt out of his deal after 2026. He is slated to make $24M in both 2027 and 2028, so he would be deciding to walk away from two years and $48M. That’s not a ton of money for a starting pitcher these days. The Padres just gave Nick Pivetta $55M last winter. Michael Wacha got $51M from the Royals the prior offseason. Jon Gray got $56M from the Rangers a few years back.

There’s a path for Berríos to have a strong season in 2026 and make the opt-out a real consideration. Though a poor season, or a lengthy injury absence, would naturally reduce the chances of that being a factor.

For now, the Jays will trudge through the final days of the season. Scherzer started Wednesday night. Thursday is going to be a bullpen game with Louis Varland technically the starter. Schultz may end up covering multiple innings of relief. Bieber and Yesavage are scheduled to take the ball in the two subsequent contests. Gausman could start the final game if it’s important or if they have secured a bye, though the Jays could also hold him for the first game of the wild-card round, if necessary. Bassitt and Berríos could re-enter the equation later in October if they get healthy as the Jays stay alive.