The Heisman Trophy race has shifted in the Big Ten's favor, with Ohio State’s Julian Sayin and Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza now emerging as favorites to win college football’s most prestigious individual award. Odds makers have placed both quarterbacks at the top of the betting boards, indicating that the one of the nation’s most competitive conference races could also determine the winner of the sport’s highest honor.
The Big Ten hasn’t produced a Heisman winner since 2006, when Ohio State quarterback Troy Smith claimed the trophy after leading the Buckeyes to an undefeated regular season. Nearly two decades later, another Ohio State quarterback is in position to follow in his footsteps with the Indiana star right beside him.
Sayin, the sophomore signal-caller who took over in Columbus this season, has lived up to his five-star billing. He’s been surgical and composed, throwing for 393 yards and four touchdowns in a 34–0 win over Wisconsin on Saturday that turned heads among voters and sportsbooks alike.
Sayin’s mix of accuracy, maturity and big-game presence has made him the face of Ohio State’s national title push. He has surpassed his teammate Jeremiah Smith and is now the the Buckeyes' leading candidate for the Heisman because of throws like this:
JULIAN SAYIN LAUNCHES IT TO CARNELL TATE! TOUCHDOWN @OhioStateFB
— FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) October 18, 2025
CBS pic.twitter.com/CduVmL4PLM
Still, the pivotal moment of his campaign might come on Nov. 29, when the Buckeyes head to Ann Arbor to face Michigan. If Sayin performs exceptionally well on the road in one of college football’s biggest rivalries, it could be the decisive moment that sets him apart from the rest of the field.
Not far behind sits Mendoza, who has turned Indiana from a solid playoff team into a legit national championship contender. The transfer quarterback has been one of the most efficient passers in the country; he's completing 73.5% of his throws and was clutch in Indiana's signature win against Oregon on the road. His consistency and leadership have made him one of the most intriguing stories in college football and a fast riser in Heisman odds over the past month.
For Mendoza, the best chance to win the award might come if Heisman voters wait to cast their ballots until after the Big Ten Championship game. If Indiana and Ohio State face off in Indianapolis, the matchup could serve as a winner-takes-all event, not just for the conference title but also for the Heisman award.
Both quarterbacks need to keep winning to stay in front. Sayin’s high-profile schedule gives him a chance to create a Heisman moment every week, while Mendoza’s steady climb and underdog story could sway voters late if the Hoosiers stay in the title hunt.
With Sayin and Mendoza now betting favorites, the Big Ten’s 19-year drought could soon end. Whether it’s the sophomore phenom from Columbus or the breakout star from Bloomington, the road to the Heisman is once again running straight through the heart of the Midwest.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!