Does extension for A.J. Preller mean Padres drama is settled?

A.J. Preller’s current contract with the Padres runs through the end of the 2026 season, but it appears as though Preller will be the team’s president of baseball operations for quite a longer time to come.  The Athletic’s Dennis Lin reports that Preller and team chairman John Seidler have had some talks about a new multi-year contract extension, and that deal could be officially in place within the next few days.  Club sources tell Lin that the team wants Preller’s new contract completed by Monday, when the team is set to introduce new manager Craig Stammen during a press conference.

The news isn’t surprising, as the Padres have enjoyed a lot of success during Preller’s 11-plus years in charge of the front office.  However, a report from Lin and Ken Rosenthal from a few weeks ago cast some doubt on Preller’s long-term future in San Diego, due to some apparent tension between Preller and team CEO Erik Greupner.  Preller downplayed any issue, telling Lin and Rosenthal that “Erik and I have been together my entire time here and enjoy a strong and productive working relationship.” 

The Padres gave Greupner a contract extension in late 2024, and around that same time, former manager Mike Shildt had also received a new deal covering the 2026-27 seasons.  There was curiosity over San Diego extending two notable organizational figures beyond Preller’s own tenure, plus Greupner and special advisor Eric Kutsenda reportedly pushed for Shildt’s hiring over Preller’s reported choice of Ryan Flaherty as the team’s latest manager.  In addition, Preller’s own hands-on approach to overseeing all facets of the organization has led to some criticisms about micro-management, and has possibly been a contributing factor to the revolving door in the manager’s office during Preller’s tenure.

If Preller is indeed nearing the finish line on a new extension, it would appear whatever disputes might’ve existed behind the scenes have been settled for now, and the team will press on ahead with Preller and new skipper Stammen now leading the charge to finally get the Padres back to the World Series.  Preller’s tenure has been marked by a lot of internal drama, managerial changes, big-ticket acquisitions, and a rebuild, yet the end result has been a steady diet of October baseball in San Diego.

The Padres have five winning records and four playoff appearances in the last six seasons, and the team made it as deep as the NLCS in 2022. Petco Park attendance and local TV ratings have gone through the roof due to this run of success, helping fund a payroll that exploded under former owner Peter Seidler.  While the Padres have cut back on the spending to some extent since Seidler’s death in 2023, Preller’s penchant for bold acquisitions have helped keep the team in position to keep contending with both its established core (i.e. Manny Machado, Fernando Tatis Jr.) and some newer faces (i.e. Mason Miller, Nick Pivetta) joining the ride.