
For 48 hours, the sky was falling in Columbus, Ohio.
Chris Henry Jr., the generational wide receiver talent and crown jewel of Ohio State’s recruiting class, took Buckeye Nation on an emotional rollercoaster that rivaled the intensity of a College Football Playoff game.
After appearing to be a lock for Ohio State, the foundation of his recruitment crumbled on National Signing Day — only to be rebuilt live on national television Friday.
Here’s a look at the chaotic events that nearly cost Ohio State its most prized recruit.
To understand the panic of the Buckyeyes, you must understand the commitment. Henry Jr. has been the face of their future since he committed to Ohio State in July 2023. The five-star prospect and son of the late NFL star seemed inextricably linked to the Buckeyes. He was the next great heir to "Zone 6," the wide receiver room that has become the NFL’s premier feeder system with players such at Marvin Harrison Jr. (Arizona Cardinals), Jaxon Smith-Njigba (Seattle Seahawks) and Garrett Wilson (New York Jets).
Despite his long-standing verbal pledge, the final stretch of modern recruiting is never safe. In the weeks leading up to signing day, powerhouse programs started making serious pushes.
Both Oregon and USC entered the mix with aggressive pitches — Oregon armed with robust NIL backing and Dan Lanning’s momentum, and USC offering the allure of staying close to his Mater Dei (California) High School. Still, heading into Wednesday morning, confidence in Columbus remained high.
The chaos ignited on Wednesday, just when letters of intent were expected to roll in. That's when news broke that Hartline, Ohio State’s co-offensive coordinator and arguably the best wide receiver recruiter in college football history, had accepted the head-coaching job at South Florida.
Afterward, Henry Jr. posted a message that sent shockwaves through the Ohio State fan base. He announced he had not signed any paperwork and would be "reevaluating" his options because of Hartline's departure.
I have not signed yet. Still trying to weigh my options due to coaching changes I just want to make the right decision for my future.
— Chris Henry Jr (@ChrisHenryJr) December 3, 2025
Gods plan
Throughout Thursday, the situation looked dire. But the narrative shifted with Hartline — the man primary architect for Henry Jr.'s development plan — gone.
Major recruiting publications and insiders began logging predictions flipping Henry Jr. from Ohio State to Oregon. The consensus was that without Hartline, the tether to Columbus was severed, and the Ducks were poised to swoop in and steal the cycle's best player at the 11th hour.
That brings us to Friday. With speculation at a fever pitch, Henry Jr. appeared on "The Pat McAfee Show" to end the drama.
"I'm staying committed to THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) December 5, 2025
It's the right fit for me and they've been in my heart ever since I committed" ~ @ChrisHenryJr #PMSLive https://t.co/JCoIbOtMks pic.twitter.com/n2KmSRye1p
Defying the "insiders," Henry Jr. announced he was sticking with Ohio State. He admitted the Hartline news was a shock, but credited Ohio State head coach Ryan Day for stablizing the situation.
Henry Jr. explained to McAfee that his commitment was to the program and the culture Day has built — not just one position coach. He reaffirmed his belief in Ryan Day’s offense and officially ended one of the most stressful recruiting sagas in recent Buckeye history.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!