
There are a couple of different ways to look at Alabama's 34-24 win over Oklahoma in the first-round of the College Football Playoff on Friday night. The first is that Alabama silenced the critics and justified the CFP committee's decision to put them in the field when their inclusion was heavily scrutinized.
It was a fair criticism at the time. It still is now.
But Alabama did what it needed to, proved its point and is advancing to the quarterfinal, where it will play No. 1 Indiana.
The other way to look at this game is that Oklahoma missed a great opportunity to make a run of its own and self-destructed in a staggering way.
Because that is the big story of the game itself.
Early in the second quarter, it appeared as if Oklahoma was going to run away with the game, run Alabama out of the stadium and validate all of the people who criticized the Crimson Tide's inclusion.
Oklahoma jumped out to a 17-0 lead and looked to be in full control.
Even after Alabama scored on a fourth-down conversion mid-way through the second quarter, Oklahoma still had a great chance to wrestle momentum back.
But that is when the self-destruction began.
The sequence of events that ended the first half was a staggering series of unforced errors by the Sooners that are going to be nightmare fuel for their fans all offseason.
It began when quarterback John Mateer found a wide-open Xavier Robinson downfield for what could have — and should have — been a touchdown to extend the lead back to 17 points. Robinson dropped the ball, forcing Oklahoma to punt.
That quickly turned into a disaster when Grayson Miller simply missed the football on his punt attempt, giving Alabama the football at the 30-yard line. That resulted in a field goal to make it a 17-10 game.
As if that was not bad enough, Mateer ended the first half by throwing an egregious pick-six to tie the game that was not even close to an Oklahoma wide receiver.
ALABAMA PICK-SIX ON JOHN MATEER pic.twitter.com/MuaaUzD7aW
— ESPN (@espn) December 20, 2025
From that point on, Alabama took over the game and never looked back, while the mistakes never stopped flowing for Oklahoma.
Mateer looked lost in the pocket while the offensive line could not hold up in pass protection.
Groza award-winning kicker Tate Sandell missed two field goals in the second half after being nearly perfect all season.
Miller shanked another bad punt that set Alabama up in a prime scoring position.
Oklahoma had two personal foul penalties that cost it 15 yards in each instance.
It was just one stunning mistake after another, contributing to a blown 17-point lead at home in a playoff game.
The concern for Alabama moving forward is going to be whether or not it can play better. Because it will need to. That might sound like a weird thing to say after a 10-point win, on the road, against a top-10 team, but Indiana is not likely to make as many mistakes as Oklahoma did in this game.
Alabama still had no running game to speak of. That will be a problem.
Quarterback Ty Simpson made some plays, but he also had some serious issues with accuracy at times.
Oklahoma's offense has struggled all season, especially with sustaining drives. Indiana and Fernando Mendoza are as good as any offense in the country and are not likely to look as lost as the Sooners did on Friday.
Alabama did what it needed to do. It silenced the critics for a week. But it also got a lot of help. There are also the biggest challenges still on the horizon.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!