
If things had gone according to plan for Mitch Marner and the Toronto Maple Leafs, he would have been one of the most popular players in the history of the franchise. He could have been, anyway. Maybe he even should have been.
But as the Toronto faithful showed on Friday night when he made his first return visit as a member of the Vegas Golden Knights, there is still a lot of anger and frustration over the missed opportunity his time with the team represents.
After spending the first nine years of his career with the Maple Leafs, Marner was made the scapegoat for the team's continued postseason failings this offseason when he was sent to the Golden Knights in a sign-and-trade deal that significantly altered the makeup of the Maple Leafs' core.
From a numbers standpoint, Marner was everything the Maple Leafs could have wanted from a No. 4 overall pick. He scored 221 goals, recorded 520 assists and tallied 741 points in 657 regular season games with the club. From the time he made his NHL debut at the start of the 2016-17 season, he was the eighth-leading point-producer in the league during his time as a Maple Leaf.
Add in the fact that he was a local product, having grown up in Toronto as a Maple Leafs fan, and it should have been a perfect match. But as the Maple Leafs fans showed on Friday, there is more bitterness than celebration about his return.
He was loudly booed during pregame warm-ups, when he first came on the ice for the game, and early on every single time he touched the puck.
The boo's were LOUD for Marner's first puck touches pic.twitter.com/JDE57uHgYP
— B/R Open Ice (@BR_OpenIce) January 24, 2026
There was a brief pause for a smattering of cheers during a pre-planned video tribute, but the booing quickly resumed.
It is a harsh reminder of how much disappointment Maple Leafs fans feel over this era in the franchise's history. The arrival of Marner, Auston Matthews and William Nylander was supposed to be the start of a championship era that would bring the Stanley Cup back to Toronto for the first time since the Original Six days.
But in nine years together, that core managed to win just two playoff series and repeatedly fell short in the biggest games. Marner was often at the center of those playoff struggles. His goal-scoring production dipped, he would routinely struggle the deeper into a series it would get, and he also had some ugly contract negotiations that dominated headlines.
Things also ended up getting personal at times. As Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman highlighted in advance of Friday's game, Marner often felt slighted by the Maple Leafs for decisions they made early in his career, ranging from not giving him a chance to play in the NHL in his age 18 season to withholding bonuses on his rookie contract over salary cap concerns. These were just some of the things that led to a bitter split between a team and a player that should have been a perfect match for each other.
Entering play on Friday, the Maple Leafs were clearly worse for letting Marner go and on the outside of the Eastern Conference playoff picture. Vegas, meanwhile, is one of the best teams in the Western Conference with Marner. He still has to rewrite the narrative about his career when it comes to the playoffs, and if he does, that is only going to look worse for Toronto, and perhaps lead to even more bitterness.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!