
One of the biggest embarrassments of the past few decades of professional football was the NFL using "replacement referees."
In 2012, the league was unable to reach a collective bargaining agreement with the NFL Referees Association. That led to a "lockout" that went 110 days and lasted three weeks into the 2012 regular season.
Terrifyingly, with the current CBA due to expire at the end of May, ESPN's Kevin Seifert is reporting that replacement refs could be on their way back.
"According to the emails, the league is looking for a list of about 150 mostly small college officials by the end of this weekend," Seifert reported on Wednesday. "Those officials could begin onboarding as early as April then attend a four-day clinic in May. Absent a CBA agreement, they would continue training through the summer and make visits to training camps before the regular season begins."
The replacement refs were a disaster, and that's not meant as a slight to them. They were literally unqualified for the job. These were referees from the high school and lower collegiate levels, with a few sprinkled in from the Arena Football League or Legends Football League.
It was a disaster that culminated in the now-infamous "Fail Mary" game between the Green Bay Packers and Seattle Seahawks.
From 13 years ago, the Fail Mary pic.twitter.com/8pFCWcbKz5
— Mike Garafolo (@MikeGarafolo) December 22, 2025
Notably, the NFL and the NFL Referees Association came to an agreement after that game, and the referee lockout was over.
Going back to that would be a disaster for the NFL in 2026, especially with the rise of legalized sports betting.
Regarding sports gambling, NFLRA executive director Scott Green told ESPN that he believes there could be a vulnerability to unscrupulous replacement refs if the NFL decides to dip into the lower levels. Player safety is obviously a concern as well.
The speed of the game is incredibly different between DII football, for example, and the NFL.
"Frankly," Green said, "I'm surprised they would even consider it after 2012."
If there is one positive update regarding these negotiations, it's that, per ESPN's Adam Schefter, the league's owners are frustrated by the way they are going.
If there's a group outside of the fans and players who would suffer from another replacement ref fiasco, it would be the owners, so perhaps they can grease the skids and get this settled before May 31.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!