
Closer Jeff Hoffman has been relieved of his closer duties following high-leverage failure concerns. The Toronto Blue Jays will follow a player-by-committee approach instead of having one primary closer.
The Blue Jays have several back-end relievers they can utilize outside of Louis Varland, such as Tyler Rogers, Mason Fluharty, Spencer Miles, Braydon Fisher and Tommy Nance. The Blue Jays also have Yimi Garcia, who is set to return from right shoulder surgery in late April/early May. Giving them plenty of depth and options of relievers to utilize late in games and in save opportunities.
They have high-leverage specialist Varland, who has demonstrated how he's a prime candidate as a closer. Three blown saves and an ERA over seven (7.59 ERA) across 12 appearances from Hoffman forced John Schneider to take immediate action. Hoffman's role will change in the pen following his early-season struggles. Hoffman developed issues with walks, which led to unforced offense and higher pitch counts, and his inability to retire batters early.
Hoffman was only able to record two out of seven save opportunities, which forced the hands of John Schneider to take him out of the closer role.
The Blue Jays' adjustment of the bullpen will take pressure off Hoffman, whose poor outings have frustrated fans
Figuring out his future status, pitching in the bullpen will be in the hands of Schneider as he places him in low-leverage situations early in games. Hoffman's most discerning outing so far this season was against the Arizona Diamondbacks, where he gave up seven runs and a grand slam to Corbin Carroll.
Before the decision to remove Hoffman as the closer, Schneider announced he was going to evaluate the closer role with Hoffman due to his struggles displayed in his April 21 performance.
Just chatted with Jeff Hoffman about the #BlueJays new closer situation. Said it’s ‘Schneider’s ship’ and he’s willing to do whatever is asked.
— Mitch Bannon (@MitchBannon) April 24, 2026
“Whatever puts the team in the best position to win. Right now, that’s not me there. We can reevaluate periodically.”
Hoffman, working to regain his confidence by avoiding high-stakes situations, will help strengthen the Blue Jays' bullpen. Having Varland, who has succeeded in handling high-leverage situations, will likely help keep the Blue Jays on the winning side in games.
Varland has a perfect ERA of 0.00 and earned his first MLB save against the Los Angeles Angels. But Eric Lauer is another option the Blue Jays could utilize in a long-relief role.
Varland has been untouchable and reliable while recording his first MLB save. He's illustrated how he's a prime high-leverage specialist and a strong option to turn to. He's demonstrated how he sustains reliability in the pen. The Blue Jays also have several back-end relievers, such as Mason Fluarty.
Trey Yesavage's return to the rotation will plausibly shift Lauer back to a bullpen role. Lauer has shown struggles early in the rotation, but can reboost his status through the long-reliever role he excelled in last season. Lauer was highly effective in the long-relief role, owning a 1.76 ERA across 30.2 innings out of the bullpen.
While Lauer has already expressed frustrations with being a bulk pitcher, it will likely have to be a role he takes on unless there is another injury or setback with Jose Berrios and Yesavage, who are on pace to return to the rotation in the coming weeks.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!