NBA News

Home

Teams

Quizzes

Watch

Newsletter

Why LeBron shouldn't join Knicks after their historic championship run

LeBron James. Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Why LeBron James shouldn't join Knicks after their historic championship run

By Mike J. Asti | Last updated Jul 4, 2026 11:30 AM ET

Add us as a preferred source on Google

For the fourth time in his career, LeBron James is a free agent and available to join any team he desires. James and his team are currently fielding offers and weighing all options. Those closest to James believe his decision will come down to happiness over money.

Always left as a "What if?" part of his career, the New York Knicks, a marquee franchise in the biggest market who have courted James at least once before, have reached out again, as confirmed by his agent Rich Paul. But also according to Paul, the Knicks becoming a championship organization for the first time in 53 years on their own may now serve as a negative in their pursuit of James.

Becoming champions on their own means LeBron James has to say no to the Kicks

"It's difficult... If the Knicks hadn't won, there'd be on board. He'd be going to the Knicks... Jalen Brunson would have to pick up the phone and say, 'It's no issue with me.' You want to respect what those guys have built. It's Jalen Brunson's show. He's earned that right. You want to respect that," explained Paul.

And he's right. As intriguing and cinematic as James on the Knicks would be no matter what circumstance, he simply can't do it now. The "What if?" story between one of the game's greatest players and the franchise that plays its home games in the most famous arena will have to live on forever.

LeBron James would never get credit for anything he would accomplish with the Knicks

Because if James jumps aboard the Knicks as the reigning champions, especially coming off such an historically dominant postseason run, he will be destined to never receive credit for anything he accomplishes in New York and he will shoulder all of the blame for any result shy of completing back-to-back titles, fair or not.

LeBron James with the Knicks would be a movie. However, he can't do it now. He cares about legacy too much to do it now. They just won it on their own. If they hadn't, it be the move. But they just did it. Even if he joins and they win again, he won't get proper credit. Not now. https://t.co/jURBManJeA
— Mike J. Asti (@MikeAsti11) July 3, 2026

James is already a four-time NBA champion himself. He's played in 10 Finals. He's cemented as an all-time great player and winner.

LeBron James' four NBA titles each hold a different level of significance

His two titles with the Miami Heat were with a team that will always be more synonymous with one of his teammates, even though James was the best player. His Cleveland Cavaliers title broke a long drought for an entire city (1964) and occurred thanks to the only comeback from down 3-1 in NBA Finals history. 2016 is eternally etched as one of the most iconic championships. He did win one with the Los Angeles Lakers, but it taking place in a bubble atmosphere during the COVID-19 pandemic creates an asterisk for some.

LeBron James helping to break the Knicks' drought would've been an epic

In an alternate universe, James being part of the Knicks capturing New York that elusive first championship since 1973 would've catapulted up his list of achievements to only sit behind his redemption journey as an Akron, Ohio native for Cleveland.

But back to reality: That angle is no longer possible. Brunson and company got that job done themselves, doing so with multiple series sweeps, a record margin of victory and a never-say-die attitude that allowed them to pull off several comeback victories to defeat the San Antonio Spurs in five games.

Knicks' interest in LeBron James makes tons of sense

It makes sense for the Knicks to be interested. James would enhance attention and ticket sales for the Knicks to an astronomical level. He would fit in on the court, assuming he's okay with being the second or third option, as he will be anywhere.

It's LeBron James, still an extremely productive player at 41 — he just averaged 20.9 points, 6.1 rebounds and 7.2 assists while shooting 51.5% from the field in 60 games for the Lakers.

Previously viewed as too dysfunctional, the Knicks are an attractive destination for any star player. However, in a sense of irony, they now can't be attractive to the biggest star of them all.

Mike J. Asti

Mike Asti is an experienced media personality and journalist with a vast resume and skillset, most notably from time with TribLIVE Radio and WPXI-TV. Asti now serves as the Managing Editor of WV Sports Now, where he leads the coverage of WVU sports. He has also covered the Steelers, Penguins, Pirates and other teams within the Pittsburgh market

More must-reads: