
The College Football Playoff gave its answer on Thursday, nine days after Mid-American Conference commissioner Jon A. Steinbrecher wrote to both the CFP and the NCAA asking that Western Michigan be recognized as the winner of its Sept. 5 game at Michigan.
In a statement to The Athletic, the playoff said it does not have the authority to change or otherwise alter the outcome of a game played during the regular season.
The NCAA's Football Bowl Subdivision Oversight Committee had reached the same conclusion on Wednesday, while siding with the MAC on the substance of the complaint. That committee found instant replay protocols were not followed on the second-to-last play and said the outcome would have been different had they been.
Michigan won 13-12 after Big Ten replay officials put one second back on the clock, and Bryce Underwood's second Hail Mary attempt found JJ Buchanan in the end zone.
The playoff added:
"The CFP Selection Committee evaluates all teams on a comprehensive body of work over a full season, driven by how teams perform in each game. The Committee's evaluation is informed by a broad range of inputs, not just wins and losses. These measures and data points include Opponent Team Strength, Schedule Strength and Record Strength, with rankings determined by comparing the full profile rather than any single metric."
New: The College Football Playoff says it, too, cannot overturn the Michigan-WMU result, in a statement to @TheAthletic.
— Chris Vannini (@ChrisVannini) September 17, 2026
Also emphasized the committee looks at more than just wins and losses. pic.twitter.com/QQIFwRTeE8
Record strength, one of the three inputs the statement names, was added to the selection committee's analysis before last season to reward teams that beat high-quality opponents while reducing the penalty for losing to one.
Michigan is 2-0 and back in the AP Top 25 at No. 19 after its 17-10 win over the Sooners, having fallen out of the poll entirely the week before. Western Michigan is still drawing AP votes, worth 35 points in the most recent poll.
A playoff berth is worth at least $4 million to the MAC and its member schools, which in a way explains the urgency behind an appeal that had no precedent. Western Michigan is left with the committee's promise to weigh a full profile, and Lance Taylor's team still has to build one worth weighing.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!