
There is no denying that the Colorado Buffaloes captivated the college football world ahead of the 2023 season when they hired Deion Sanders.
"Coach Prime" generated an enormous amount of media attention after his arrival, and with his son Shedeur at quarterback, Sanders had a successful first two seasons.
Fast forward to present day, though, and a horrendous 2025 season (3-9) followed by turmoil and poor on-field results so far in 2026 could be a signal that Sanders' time at Colorado needs to come to an end.
The Buffaloes dropped their Week 4 game Saturday, 23-13, against Baylor. Prior to that, Colorado was in the news after Sanders announced that a couple of players were no longer with the program after a postgame incident in Week 3.
Saturday's game was a chance to turn the page and move past the incident, but more on-field issues popped up. That included quarterback Julian Lewis being benched in the loss. Cameras also captured Lewis' coach appearing to tell him to "stop being scared" just ahead of his benching.
"Stop being scared"
— Underdog CFB (@UnderdogCFB) September 26, 2026
Colorado QB Julian Lewis was benched shortly after this clip of his offensive coordinator aired pic.twitter.com/680fIl7VB3
Coach Prime says it was his decision to take Julian Lewis out of the game:
— DNVR Buffs (@DNVR_Buffs) September 26, 2026
“I’ll take responsibility…
It was a decision I made because I was trying to get us going.” pic.twitter.com/waktRcUvmi
With things seeming to be on a downward trajectory, it really begs the question of how much longer Sanders can remain at Colorado. The energy and juice that the program had when he first took over is no longer present, and it's obvious the culture isn't, either.
It was a fun story in the first few seasons, but there also comes a time when results and winning take priority over anything else.
A brutal schedule for the remainder of the season will likely keep Colorado out of a bowl game for the second straight season, and conversations surrounding the future of the program should get rather loud if that becomes reality.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!