
Each week, Yardbarker spotlights college football stars, some of whom will be playing on NFL Sundays. With that in mind, here are five Week 5 standouts.
ESPN analyst Pat McAfee shouldn't have doubted Carr's accuracy. Before Notre Dame's road game against the North Carolina Tar Heels, the QB drilled the crossbar from 30 yards away. After losing the challenge, the "College GameDay" personality agreed to donate $250K to a charity of the passer's choosing at a later date.
Carr then used his pinpoint passing to shred Tar Heels head coach Bill Belichick's defense. In a 37-26 win, the QB completed 21-of-29 passes for 234 yards and four touchdowns. He also rushed for a three-yard TD.
"Watching Carr today reminded me of [Hall of Famer] Tom Brady in person: The pre-snap maneuvering can almost become boring until you appreciate how surgical it is," wrote The Ringer's Todd McShay in his Sunday column. "Carr understands what he's reading, where the ball should go, and which play gives his offense his best chance."
CJ CARR DRILLS THE CROSSBAR @PatMcAfeeShow will donate $250,000 to a charity of CJ’s choosing pic.twitter.com/zKQ5FKQ2lY
— College GameDay (@CollegeGameDay) October 3, 2026
CJ Carr on the money to Jordan Faison pic.twitter.com/UWqY8DPci6
— ESPN College Football (@ESPNCFB) October 3, 2026
Carr's grandfather, former Michigan Wolverines HC Lloyd Carr, coached Brady from 1995-99. Perhaps he showed him tape on the former New England Patriots QB to teach him the position. Whether he did or not, CJ Carr's putting his grandfather's wisdom to good use, which has him in the first-round discussion. In Tankathon's latest mock draft, the Minnesota Vikings select him with pick No. 31.
Last season, Ole Miss Rebels senior QB Trinidad Chambliss replaced Simmons after he struggled early and suffered an ankle injury. At Missouri, he's escaping Chambliss' shadow.
In a 45-17 home upset win over the Florida Gators on Saturday, Simmons went 23-of-30 passing for 340 yards and two TDs. The QB is now tied for ninth in the country in TD passes (13 in five games).
The ball just sizzles out of Austin Simmons' hand.
— Jordan Reid (@Jordan_Reid) October 3, 2026
Easy arm strength. pic.twitter.com/sO8wW4qXbm
"The lefty has a loose and live arm to sling the ball with unforced velocity to every inch of the field," wrote The Athletic's Dane Brugler on Sunday. "He is very much on the NFL radar."
Simmons, who turns 21 on Nov. 8, has one more year of eligibility after the 2026 season. But his stock will keep skyrocketing if he keeps producing elite numbers, which may convince him he's ready to enter the 2027 NFL Draft (scheduled April 29-May 1 in Washington).
Ohio State junior WR Jeremiah Smith should be making a trip to the 2026 Heisman Trophy ceremony on Dec. 12 in New York after breaking the program's records for receptions (207) and TD catches (36) in a 31-14 road win over the Iowa Hawkeyes. Sayin may be joining him on that trip.
Against Iowa, 2025 Heisman finalist Sayin threw for 324 yards and three TDs on 20-of-27 passes. The Ohio State star now leads the nation in QBR (92.1) and ranks fourth in passing yards (1,530).
RE-WRITE THE RECORD BOOKS.
— Ohio State Football (@OhioStateFB) October 3, 2026
YOUR NEW ALL TIME RECEIVING TOUCHDOWNS LEADER, JEREMIAH SMITH. pic.twitter.com/FjFo28YFsA
Brugler wrote Sayin has an "NFL future" but needs more tape to convince teams he's a first-rounder. Scouts still have questions about his size (6-foot-1, 214 pounds) and athleticism.
If Sayin lands in the right situation, he could follow a similar path to San Francisco 49ers fifth-year QB Brock Purdy. Like Sayin, Purdy (6-foot-1, 220 pounds) is a smaller QB, but his accuracy offsets that concern. Purdy completed 71.7 percent of his passes in his final season with the Iowa State Cyclones; Sayin has completed 72.5 percent of his passes through five games this season.
Duff makes a 1-4 Rutgers squad watchable.
In a 47-15 blowout loss to the Indiana Hoosiers, the star wideout produced one of Rutgers' few highlights. In the second quarter, he made a 41-yard one-handed grab while falling. He finished with four receptions for 78 yards.
KJ Duff is REALLY GOOD at football #Rutgers
— Rutgers Scarlet Knights | The Knight Report (@RutgersOn3) October 4, 2026
https://t.co/LUik1i0jOR pic.twitter.com/g1vszNkNqO
Duff now ranks third in the FBS in receiving yards (628 on 33 receptions) and fifth in TD catches (seven). His numbers and penchant for making ridiculous catches make him a potential first-rounder. Tankathon has the Kansas City Chiefs taking him with pick No. 32.
Pro Football Network noted Duff is an "unorthodox prospect" because of his height (6-foot-6, 225 pounds) but projects as a clear NFL starter.
Minnesota beat Michigan at home for the first time since 1977 in a 20-14 victory. Johnson may have been the offensive player of the game in the program's historic win.
Johnson, who started his second game at center, allowed no pressures (via Pro Football Focus), which is even more impressive considering that Michigan's defense features NFL prospects in edge-rushers John Henry Daley and Dom Nichols.
With his performance against Michigan, Johnson is continuing to establish himself as the No. 1 interior O-lineman in the draft. On his latest big board, ESPN's Jordan Reid ranks him No. 15 among 50 players.
"Johnson [6-foot-6, 325 pounds] is a hulking interior blocker whose strength helps him latch and sustain the point of attack," Reid wrote.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!