Texas HC Steve Sarkisian's right about Arch Manning's last name creating unfair criticism — but QB must learn to accept it

Sarkisian mentioned that Arch Manning's four wins over Associated Press top-10 opponents are one reason he deserves more credit. He delivered one of those victories this season. 

Arch Manning led the Longhorns to a 24-23 comeback win over the then-ranked No. 1 Ohio State Buckeyes in Week 2 after trailing 23-3 in the third quarter. The QB, however, produced pedestrian numbers, completing 23-of-37 passes (62.2 percent) for 195 yards and tossing one touchdown and one interception.

Those numbers have been the norm for Arch Manning in 2026. Through five starts, he has completed 63 percent of his passes for 1,122 yards, throwing 10 TDs and five interceptions. 

Surprisingly, Arch Manning hasn't taken the next step after he finished strong in 2025, tying for 17th in the nation in TD passes (26 in 13 games). The lack of progress raises questions about his ability to read defenses. Sarkisian said he doesn't think the QB is struggling to process information, but Fox analyst Joel Klatt disagrees.

"He doesn't process information all that quickly," the former Colorado Buffaloes QB said in a clip posted to X Monday. "His eyes tend to be in the wrong spot at times. You saw that on the last interception [against Oklahoma]."

Many assumed the heir to the Manning family would've mastered many of these skills, but they're not innate. They're acquired through experience, and the Texas standout clearly needs more of it.

So, has Arch Manning's last name often created unrealistic expectations and made him the brunt of unfair criticism? Yes. That said, the QB must accept it. He can't run from his family name. Sarkisian must keep helping Arch Manning navigate those challenges as he and the Longhorns (4-1) prepare for Saturday's home game against the Florida Gators (4-2). The contest kicks off at noon ET on ABC.