
New York Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner choosing to retain team vice president/general manager Brian Cashman and manager Aaron Boone after the club was eliminated by the Tampa Bay Rays in the American League Division Series round of this year's postseason tournament remains an unpopular decision among pockets of passionate Yankees fans.
During a recent conversation with Bob Klapisch of NJ Advance Media, former MLB pitcher and current YES analyst David Cone made it clear he disagrees with those who wanted Steinbrenner to show at least Boone the door in October.
"I think Aaron Boone is outstanding at what he does," Cone explained. "His personality is well-suited for the modern-day managerial position. Now, if you want to critique him in his post-game (press conferences) and say, 'I wish we’d see a little more of this or a little more of that,' that’s certainly fair. Maybe you’d like to see a little less protectiveness of the players. But if you’re a player, you love that. That’s probably why the players really do love him. But there’s always a shelf life. It’s hard to be a manager, especially nowadays."
A report from late October noted that one reason free agents and others want to play for the Yankees is that Boone "takes the punches for" his players. That's all well and good, but Yankees fans mostly care about the fact that Boone guided the team to just one World Series appearance and no championships from 2018 through this fall. Boone's contract runs through next season, and his eventual replacement may soon start working for the Yankees.
"Boone is coming up on close to 10 years with the Yankees, where he’s the spokesman," Cone continued. "He’s the guy you hear before the games, after the game. You hear the same sort of things over and over, and the shelf life kind of gets to you a little bit. As a fan, you need, you want to hear something different. That’s not a knock. That’s just the nature of the game."
Jorge Posada, Anthony Rizzo and CC Sabathia are among former Yankees players who criticized aspects of the team's clubhouse and roster construction following the series against the Rays. Cone offered a strong response to those comments.
"I find it really hard to criticize when you’re not in the middle of it, when you’re not in that clubhouse," Cone told Klapisch. "It’s easy to take shots when you’re on the outside looking in. We don’t know for sure what goes on behind those closed doors. It’s a bit surprising hearing all that because ex-players should know better than anyone else. Unless you’re inside the clubhouse, then you really don’t know what’s going on. The ex-players need to be more specific. You need to come with receipts. I’m a broadcaster who covers this team, and even I don’t know what [team captain Aaron Judge] says to Jazz Chisholm. That’s why I’m very reluctant to be critical of the way they handle their business."
Such offseason conversations won't matter once the expected lockout ends and regular-season games get underway in 2027. As of the afternoon of Nov. 17, it was difficult to imagine Steinbrenner would run it back with Boone once again if the Yankees aren't part of the next World Series.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!