x
RJ Luis eligibility saga leaves everyone mad at everyone
RJ Luis. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

RJ Luis eligibility saga leaves everyone mad at everyone

The never-ending eligibility saga of LSU Tigers guard RJ Luis Jr. reached another gear on Thursday.

One day after Luis, who previously played in the NBA during 2025-26 preseason for the Boston Celtics, made his LSU debut, university president Wade Rousse released a statement revealing he had "instructed LSU men's basketball coach Will Wade not to play" the 2024-25 Big East Player of the Year.

It's the latest development in a saga that's had more twists and turns over the past month than most soap operas.

As a refresher, in October, an East Baton Rouge judge issued an injunction barring the SEC from punishing LSU for placing Luis on its roster after he was previously granted another injunction allowing him to play on Aug. 24. 

Initially, Wade elected not to add Luis, who he recruited during the offseason, telling reporters in October, "We're going to follow all the SEC protocols with him. I think it's been pretty clear what the SEC protocols are on all that." Earlier this year, the conference passed rules banning players who previously signed professional contracts.

But that's where things kicked into overdrive.

Last Friday, per The Athletic's Brendan Marks, a different East Baton Rouge judge prohibited the university, NCAA, SEC or conference commissioner Greg Sankey "from 'refusing to allow RJ Luis Jr. to be a member of the LSU men's basketball team and to practice, participate and compete with the team throughout the 2026-27 season."

The SEC then gave the green light for Luis to play, with SEC attorney Donald Price writing in a letter to Luis' representatives that the conference would "abide by the terms of the preliminary injunction while it remains in place and will not impose penalties or fines on LSU."

It sang a different tune less than 24 hours later after Luis was officially added to the roster, with the SEC writing in a statement that "LSU's decision ... to rely on its own interpretation of the Court's order to justify its actions is inconsistent with the expectations ... of membership in the Southeastern Conference."

The whole situation is a mess, leaving everyone angry at everyone. But who exactly is mad at who? Below, we dissect the animosity from all angles.

SEC vs. LSU

The SEC was so mad at LSU after football coach Lane Kiffin tried to add former NFL pros (and later joked about not being able to at halftime of a win over Clemson) that it threatened to kick the university out of the conference, citing a "lack of institutional control." Two months later, it's "deeply disturbed" with the successful effort to play Luis.

The conference has taken the role of an exasperated parent as LSU plays with matches while running with scissors.

LSU vs. Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr

Few have been more vocal in expressing their desire for LSU to be kicked to the curb than Carr, who most recently accused the university of "attempting to benefit from the legal chaos it helped to coordinate and encourage."

During the football eligibility drama, Carr wrote a letter imploring the conference to take action "including suspending and/or removing LSU from the conference."

At every turn, Carr has been there calling for heads to roll. As revenge, LSU will have to ban Chick-fil-A and peaches from its campus.

U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon vs. Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill

On Wednesday, Axon shredded lawyers representing LSU for writing in a filing that SEC attorneys had "hallucinated" certain case citations.

"I have to tell you I'm so disappointed," Axon said, demanding that the university and Murrill apologize for the mischaracterization. 

Murrill defied the request, and in response, argued that it was a matter of "free speech," or more precisely, "the right not to speak," citing "'the compelled speech doctrine' [prohibiting] government compulsion of speech."

As laid out by both Above The Law's Joe Patrice and Tom Mars, that's a, um, bold strategy. 

RJ Luis Jr.'s representatives vs. Greg Sankey

The unquestionable greatest thing to come from this whole ordeal was when an attorney for Luis colorfully referred to the SEC commissioner as "Kim Jong" Sankey, in reference to North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, after winning the October ruling.

More recently, Luis' representation filed a motion seeking to hold Sankey and the SEC in contempt of court over its remarks about being "deeply concerned" over their client's addition to the LSU roster.

As long as the checks keep clearing, this fight, and maybe even the name-calling, isn't ending.

Will Wade vs. Wade Rousse

Wade went against LSU once before back in 2019 when he refused to cooperate with an investigation over a recruiting scandal that ultimately landed a middleman in federal prison. What's to say he won't defy LSU president Wade Rousse's order?

The two have a friendly history from their time together at McNeese, but the inconsistent messaging from the top has done Wade no favors, potentially fraying the relationship.

Fans vs. NCAA

Above all else, fans should be mad at the NCAA for putting college athletics in a place where a former professional can convince a friendly judge that he should be eligible. 

Earlier this month, Tennessee Volunteers men's basketball showed that enforceable rules are possible when they released the term sheet of a collective bargaining agreement, which would only ever be realistic if the NCAA dropped the charade and allowed athletes to unionize as employees.

Instead, it's chosen chaos. And now, we're all living in it.

Eric Smithling

Eric Smithling is a writer based in New Orleans, LA, whose byline also appears on Athlon Sports. He has been with Yardbarker since September 2022, primarily covering the NFL and college football, but also the NBA, WNBA, men’s and women’s college basketball, NHL, tennis and golf. He holds a film studies degree from the University of New Orleans. You can find him on X and Threads at @ericsmithling and at Bluesky at @ericsmithling.bsky.social.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!