x
Numbers show MLB fans on both sides of lockout, and that's why nobody's blinking
A view of a baseball. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Numbers show MLB fans on both sides of lockout, and that's why nobody's blinking

Major League Baseball fans have spoken ... and they've said two things at once.

A Seton Hall Sports Poll, conducted Oct. 8-13 and released on Nov. 18, found 54 percent of MLB fans support a salary cap in the next collective bargaining agreement while only 19 percent oppose one.

The same poll asked who fans would blame for a stoppage. Of those polled, 39 percent said the owners and 28 percent said the players.

Read those two numbers together, and you get the whole problem. The owners are demanding the cap, the players are fighting it and the fans are backing the owners' policy while blaming the owners for the fight.

Daniel Ladik, PhD, the poll's methodologist, flagged it himself.

"I find it interesting that most fans support a salary cap yet and at the same time, support the players more than the owners. The players do not support a salary cap while the owners do," Ladik said. "If a work stoppage does occur post November 30th, it looks like it will be a long, drawn-out affair."

He's right, and Wednesday showed why. At the owners' meetings in New York, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred drew a line and cited the fans.

"I will say there's plenty of room for compromise," Manfred said, per ESPN's Jorge Castillo. "But there's one thing I will not compromise, and that's the issue that we're hearing from the vast majority of our fans: They want salary cap and floor, and on that, we will not compromise."

Manfred added he can't imagine the owners ratifying a deal without a cap and floor in it.

He's not making the polling up. Seton Hall has 54 percent. The Athletic's survey of 14,154 fans had 68 percent backing a cap and floor, up from 59 percent in 2022. A Morning Consult poll the league has cited put support at 79 percent among avid fans.

But the union is walking in with numbers as well, citing 39 percent of fans blame the owners for a stoppage against 28 percent who blame the players. And Wednesday, MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer said the owners' push for a cap is about profit, not parity.

"They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries," Meyer said in a statement.

So it seems both sides can claim the fans. The owners can say the fans want their system and the union can say the fans blame the owners. Neither claim is wrong ... and that's the trap.

The poll number that could matter most about MLB fans

There's one more number in the poll, and it might matter most. Fifty-one percent of MLB fans say a work stoppage would not reduce their interest once games resume. Fans said the same thing in March 2022 after the last lockout, with 51 percent saying the stoppage hadn't reduced their interest. And they came back.

That's reassuring … and it's also why this could drag. Neither side fears losing the fans. The owners don't think a lockout costs them the audience; the players don't think it costs them sympathy. The fans have told both sides they'll be there when the games come back, which means neither side has a reason to blink first.

The owners' latest proposal is a cap of $258.2 million and a floor of $180.2 million, delayed until 2028. The union has rejected every version of a cap and countered with a $300 million luxury-tax threshold. The current agreement expires Dec. 1 at 11:59 p.m. ET, and a lockout is expected to begin on Dec. 2.

Twelve days out, the fans have given both sides exactly what they wanted ... a poll that says the cap is popular, and a poll that says the owners are to blame. The only thing they haven't given anybody is a reason to settle.

Kevin Henry

A member of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA), Kevin Henry has been covering MLB and MiLB for nearly two decades. Those assignments have included All-Star Games and the MLB postseason, including the World Series. Based in the Denver area, Kevin calls Coors Field his home base, but travels throughout North America during the season to discover the best stories possible.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!