News Images

He's Not a Keeper But a £50M Blunder: Why Onana’s Man Utd Days Are Done

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Andy Hageman | Last updated May 8, 2025 1:04 PM ET

Manchester United’s 2023 signing of Andre Onana for $44 million from Inter Milan was meant to secure their goalkeeping future. However, persistent errors have cast doubt on his role as the club’s No. 1. Meanwhile, Inter’s replacement, Yann Sommer, earned Man of the Match honors in their 2025 Champions League semi-final, highlighting a stark contrast and at a fraction of the price.

This kind of blunder sums up United's recruitment perfectly

Inter Milan, after selling Onana, signed Sommer from Bayern Munich for circa $6 million. Sommer’s stellar performances, including a Serie A title and a Champions League final run, have vindicated Inter’s decision. His recent heroics against Barcelona underscore the gap between the two keepers.

Amorim has reportedly prioritized other positions for the 2025 summer transfer window, suggesting Onana may get another chance. However, United’s scouting network has been active, with names like Porto’s Diogo Costa and Espanyol’s Joan Garcia linked. These targets indicate contingency plans are in place.

Diogo Costa, a 25-year-old Portuguese international, carries a $66 million release clause and interest from Manchester City. Joan Garcia, a 23-year-old La Liga standout, has a more affordable $22 million price tag. Both represent younger, potentially more reliable options.

Onana’s struggles have drawn criticism, with former United midfielder Nemanja Matic calling him one of the club’s worst-ever keepers. Yet, some within United believe his issues stem from pressure rather than a lack of skill. This internal debate complicates any decision to replace him.

Could redemption come tonight: Red Devils Eye $100M Prize in Europa League Showdown with Bilbao

The financial aspect looms large—United could sell Onana for as low as $26 million, a significant loss on their investment. Interest from Saudi Arabia offers a potential exit route. However, no concrete offers have been made.

United’s goalkeeping saga reflects broader challenges under Amorim’s rebuild. Fans are frustrated, but the club’s hesitation to act swiftly suggests faith in Onana’s redemption. Only time will tell if he can silence his critics.

Good Money After Bad: From Champs to Chumps with the Glazer Family.

Sommer’s success at Inter serves as a reminder of what United hoped for with Onana. As the transfer window nears, United must weigh loyalty against the need for reliability. Unfortunately, Onana appears to make a big mistake too often for a Red Devils goalkeeper.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: