In recent summers, Manchester United have exhibited a troubling pattern: slow decision-making, rigid negotiation tactics, and a lack of sensitivity to evolving market dynamics. This recurring approach is once again reflected in the club’s current situation. At a time when intelligent rebuilding is essential, United cannot afford to remain tied to players who are underperforming, struggling to adapt, or openly seeking a way out.
One such name at the centre of this crossroads is Antony. The pressure of an underwhelming season, the constraints of financial fair play, and the growing discontent within the squad are converging, and Antony is at the heart of it.
According to Diario de Sevilla, the 25-year-old Brazilian winger remains closely linked with Real Betis and has made no effort to hide his desire for a return to Spain, frequently dropping hints on social media. For their part, Betis have proposed realistic alternatives, including a co-ownership model with an initial payment of €20 million.
However, Manchester United remain firm in their stance, insisting on a permanent sale for €35 million, a price tag that Real Betis simply cannot meet at this time. The English club, needing funds to finance incoming transfers, believes that compromising on Antony’s valuation would weaken their hand in future negotiations. As a result, all offers from the Andalusian side have been rejected so far.
From a pragmatic perspective, though, United may need to reconsider. Holding out for for a player who has failed to make an impact at Old Trafford, and who currently has a limited market, risks backfiring. Antony has made it clear he wants to leave, and his growing frustration is beginning to show. His behaviour, increasingly noticeable, threatens to create unnecessary tension within the squad.
Rather than focusing on extracting maximum value, the club is fostering a situation that could spiral into a larger issue. Betis, despite their financial constraints, have approached the deal with creativity. Their co-ownership proposal wasn’t ideal, but it was a fair compromise. United’s outright rejection of that offer may have prematurely closed one of the few realistic exit routes for the Brazilian.
Betting everything on a permanent sale risks leaving Antony sidelined, further diminishing his market value. In an era where every euro matters, holding on to an unmotivated player purely out of commercial pride could ultimately cost the club more than any loan or part-exchange deal.
Antony is neither irreplaceable nor indispensable. If his exit can help balance the books, trim the squad, and prevent internal unrest, then Manchester United must be pragmatic. Not every negotiation must come from a position of strength, sometimes, a tactical concession is the smartest path forward. If Betis return with a slightly improved offer and no better alternatives materialise, clinging to the Brazilian would be both a sporting and financial misstep.
Meanwhile, a new question emerges: should Manchester United consider a potential swap deal involving Antony for Douglas Luiz?
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!