Tim Heitman-Imagn Images

Newcastle United to battle Manchester United for rising £55m Premier League star

Originally posted on We All Follow United
By Rohit Sarkar | Last updated Oct 24, 2025 3:18 PM ET

Newcastle United want to re-sign Elliot Anderson from Nottingham Forest but Manchester United remain keen

Manchester United have started identifying midfield reinforcements for the next transfer window in January. One name quietly making its way into their discussions is Elliot Anderson. The 22-year-old has grown into a fine midfielder since leaving Newcastle United.

He has established himself at Nottingham Forest and earned a place in the England squad. The English midfielder’s technical skill and infectious energy have turned him from a promising academy graduate into a player who now plays at the top level.

According to iNews, Newcastle United are exploring the idea of bringing Anderson back to St James’ Park after they sold him last year to comply with Profit and Sustainability Rules. However, the Magpies do not hold a buy-back clause. His current value could reach nearly £55 million. That figure shows us how much Anderson has improved at Forest, where he performs consistently every week.

Newcastle’s renewed interest makes sense, though it carries emotional weight since the club once chose financial rules over his progress. Manchester United, meanwhile, are watching Anderson closely. They believe that the 22-year-old can form a strong partnership with Bruno Fernandes in midfield. Interestingly, we reported earlier that Manchester United plan to offer Casemiro a new contract, and that shows the club’s plan to blend experience with young quality.

Why Manchester United might tempt Elliot Anderson?

Anderson’s next step will likely depend on what he values more, career ambition or emotional connection. If he signs for Manchester United, then it would give him a chance to join a club that expects success and has stronger resources. It would also give the Englishman a better shot at winning trophies.

For a player entering his prime, that path holds clear appeal. Yet, the emotional pull of returning to Newcastle United will stay strong in his mind. Rejoining his boyhood club would let him reconnect with supporters who never stopped believing in him. It would help him write a brighter chapter after his earlier exit.

Still, signs suggest that Manchester United now lead the chase. The Red Devils’ management is taking concrete steps to bring him to Old Trafford. They see him as a midfielder who can refresh their system. Anderson has shown steady growth at Forest and now represents England.

United’s stage may attract him more than sentiment. While Forest stated in September that they do not want to sell Manchester United target Elliot Anderson, his ambition and United’s persistence could still push this move forward. If that happens, Anderson will complete a full circle. He will rise from a Newcastle prospect to a Manchester United regular within just a few defining seasons.

This article first appeared on We All Follow United and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: