x

Manchester United manager Mauricio Pochettino cannot fix the club’s systemic problems — only the owners can, according to a critical analysis published Tuesday, November 17, 2026.

Pochettino’s role is defined narrowly: galvanize the fanbase, improve individual players, and lift United up the Premier League table. He is not tasked with — nor equipped to deliver — cultural or structural reform. His average tenure across his past three managerial jobs is 18 months.

The analysis underscores deep-rooted instability at Old Trafford. In the 33 months since Sir Jim Ratcliffe and INEOS assumed control of football operations, Manchester United have won just 35 of 99 Premier League matches and cycled through four managers. The club has recorded a financial loss in each of the past seven seasons and won only two domestic cups during that span.

Ownership decisions are scrutinized as central to the dysfunction. Avram Glazer told investors in September that United’s commercial strength does not depend on sporting success — citing the New York Yankees (last World Series win in 2009) and Dallas Cowboys (no divisional-round win in over 40 years). The analysis calls that statement “silly and tone-deaf,” noting that top football clubs derive roughly one-third of revenue from prize money — making on-field performance financially material.

Ratcliffe’s leadership is criticized for costly turnover: more than $35 million spent on severance for fired coaches and sporting directors — a figure nearing $50 million if AC Milan’s hiring of Ruben Amorim shortly after his sacking is factored in. Sporting director Dan Ashworth lasted just five months before being dismissed.

Omar Berrada, hired as chief executive from Manchester City, joined United while City faced a Premier League investigation into false accounting, financial rule breaches, and off-the-books payments. City was found guilty in September 2026; Berrada served 13 years at City, including as chief operating officer and commercial director.

Current sporting director Jason Wilcox — a former Manchester City academy coach and ex-Southampton manager — has drawn criticism for transfer activity. He rarely speaks publicly outside United’s in-house media. Performance director Sam Erith and chief scout Kyle Macaulay also face external scrutiny, though both bring elite credentials: Erith spent a decade at City and worked with the New York Knicks and Rangers; Macaulay built his reputation at Brighton & Hove Albion, widely regarded as England’s gold standard for recruitment.

The analysis argues that accountability — not scapegoating — is required. Questions about empowerment, decision-making authority, and internal assessment mechanisms remain unanswered. Without credible top-down review and consequences, Pochettino risks becoming “a highly paid lightning rod” whose departure follows the same midseason pattern as his predecessors.

The piece concludes that Manchester United needs a culture of accountability and responsibility — one Pochettino alone cannot install, nor should be expected to lead.

Photo: Peter Glaser baraida / Wikimedia Commons, CC0
More: Premier League · Soccer · Manchester United

This article first appeared on Ball Exclusives and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!