Yardbarker
x
Who really wins in the Johnny Cardoso transfer war? – Opinion
ANP

There have been a lot of speculation surrounding a possible Tottenham Hotspur transfer for USMNT midfielder Johnny Cardoso, especially considering the fact that Daniel Levy had negotiated a transfer clause that could give the North Londoners an advantage to secure his signature in the ongoing summer transfer window.

We will have to jog back to last summer when the Lilywhites successfully negotiated a preferential purchase option to bring Johnny Cardoso to N17, which was a part of Giovani Lo Celso’s permanent transfer to Real Betis. It was a €25 million clause which, at the time, many praised as another of Levy’s masterstrokes, thinking that the 23-year-old (given his potential) would develop quickly into a menace of a midfielder. While this clause was not binding on the player, it did give the Lilywhites a right to match or exceed other offers, but if I look back at it today, the clause ended up being a commercial leverage for Betis rather than a pathway that Tottenham wanted to create.

Cardoso has developed into a really good player since moving to Betis; he has evolved into a regular asset, making invaluable contributions from the middle of the park. He is now also a regular international for the US men’s team, making his commercial value higher since moving to the La Liga giants. And let’s admit it, the way that he plays in a possession-based yet tactically disciplined manner with a high work rate suits Diego Simeone’s Atletico Madrid system at least more than what the Lilywhites had under Ange.

But if we think about it, Betis were playing the real game all along…

What the Spanish side went on to do was to utilise the North Londoners’ clause to start a bidding war while knowing that the 23-year-old is personally leaning towards a move to Atletico Madrid. While Simeone’s side made a bid of €30 million for Cardoso and Betis were holding firm at €40 million (which I do think was more of a strategic silence), and by resisting Tottenham’s clause, they reframed the way it was looked at in more of a floor sense and not a ceiling.

So now Betis are near to maximising the profit that they can make by some smart workings.

To me this does reveal something deeper; see, the thing is that preferential clauses don’t hold a lot of importance if the player is not willing, and while the Premier League remains the biggest league in the world, the Lilywhites (at the moment) don’t have that competitiveness about them as compared to clubs like Atletico Madrid or even Bayer Leverkusen to a certain extent.

And moreover, the current managerial situation is complemented by one too many deadwood midfielders in the squad complementing Cardoso’s choice.

TTLB Opinion

To us, Betis have won this transfer, hands down. They make a substantial profit while Atletico Madrid wins it tactically. And for the North Londoners, it’s a failure to close the deal despite having a structural advantage going into the negotiations. Questions need to be raised on Daniel Levy and his working, given how this is not the first time the club chairman has failed to close the deal.

This article first appeared on To The Lane And Back and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!