An egregious umpiring call may have cost Alexander Zverev the French Open title on Sunday.
During the deciding fifth set, Zverev surrendered an early break to Carlos Alcaraz but was on the verge of getting his break back to tie the set at 2-2. When Alcaraz was down 40-15, he nearly double-faulted with a second serve that was called out, but the chair umpire overturned the call. Subsequently, Alcaraz would hold serve to take a commanding 3-1 lead in the fifth set and ultimately prevail with the victory.
It was later revealed, via Hawk-Eye technology, that the chair umpire made the wrong call, costing Zverev the chance to tie the fifth set. When the call was overturned in real time, Zverev pleaded with the umpire to get a better look before pronouncing his verdict, but to no avail.
Zverev not happy with the umpire in the 5th set against Alcaraz at Roland Garros.
— The Tennis Letter (@TheTennisLetter) June 9, 2024
Break point down, Carlos hits a second serve that was called out.
The umpire overrules it.
The visual on tv says it was out by 2 mm.
Tough. pic.twitter.com/cofm3Pv7A0
So, why did the umpire not rely on technology to get the call right?
It's simple: umpires at Roland Garros do not have access to the Hawk-Eye line-calling system, which is only used for the benefit of television networks, meaning us viewers can spot an error they can't.
Why is that, you ask? On clay courts, the ball leaves a prominent mark on the surface upon impact, and the organizers have preferred to use these marks as a reference point for challenges. Unlike on other surfaces, the French Open still relies on an umpire climbing down from their chair and analyzing the ball's landing spot to either agree or disagree with the line judge's call.
The antiquated system seemed to have cost Zverev dearly on Sunday.
"It's frustrating in the end, but it is what it is," Zverev said, via Reuters. "Umpires make mistakes. They're also human and that's okay. But of course, in a situation like that, you wish there wouldn't be mistakes. But it is what it is. Look, he [Alcaraz] played fantastic. He played better than me in the fourth and fifth sets."
Zverev acknowledged the fifth set could have "gone the other way" if the umpire hadn't robbed him of a service break. After all, tennis is a sport of momentum swings.
Here's hoping the incident propels the organizers of Roland Garros to finally embrace technology.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!